After studying this chapter, students will be able to: • Describe the importance of critical thinking in nursing. • Contrast the characteristics of “novice thinking” with those of “expert thinking.” • Explain the purpose and phases of the nursing process. • Differentiate between nursing orders and medical orders. • Explain the differences between independent, interdependent, and dependent nursing actions. • Describe evaluation and its importance in the nursing process. • Define clinical judgment in nursing practice and explain how it is developed. • Devise a personal plan to use in developing sound clinical judgment. To enhance your understanding of this chapter, try the Student Exercises on the Evolve site at http://evolve.elsevier.com/Black/professional. Chapter opening photo from istockphoto.com. Defining “critical thinking” is a complex task that requires an understanding of how people think through problems. Educators and philosophers struggled with definitions of critical thinking for several decades. Two decades ago, the American Philosophical Association published an expert consensus statement (Box 8-1) describing critical thinking and attributes of the ideal critical thinker. This expert statement, still widely used, was the culmination of 3 years of work by Facione and others who synthesized the work of numerous persons who had defined critical thinking. More recently, Facione (2006) noted that giving a definition of critical thinking that can be memorized by the learner is actually antithetical to critical thinking! This means that the very definition of critical thinking does not lend itself to simplistic thinking and memorization. The Paul-Elder Critical Thinking Framework is grounded in this definition of critical thinking: Paul and Elder (2012) go on to describe a “well-cultivated critical thinker” as one who does the following: • Raises questions and problems and formulates them clearly and precisely • Gathers and assesses relevant information, using abstract ideas for interpretation • Arrives at conclusions and solutions that are well-reasoned and tests them against relevant standards • Is open-minded and recognizes alternative ways of seeing problems, and has the ability to assess the assumptions, implications, and consequences of alternative views of problems • Communicates effectively with others as solutions to complex problems are formulated We live in a “new knowledge economy” driven by information and technology that changes quickly. Analyzing and integrating information across an increasing number of sources of knowledge requires that you have flexible intellectual skills. Being a good critical thinker makes you more adaptable in this new economy of knowledge (Lau and Chan, 2012). An excellent website on critical thinking can be found at http://philosophy.hku.hk/think/ (OpenCourseWare on critical thinking, logic, and creativity). So what does this have to do with nursing? The answer is very simple: excellent critical thinking skills are required for you to make good clinical judgments. You will be responsible and accountable for your own decisions as a professional nurse. The development of critical thinking skills is crucial as you provide nursing care for patients with increasingly complex conditions. Critical thinking skills provide you with a powerful means of determining patient needs, interpreting physician orders, and intervening appropriately. Box 8-2 presents an example of the importance of critical thinking in the provision of safe care. Nurses just beginning to pay attention to their thinking processes may ask these questions after nurse–patient interactions have ended. This is known as reflective thinking. Reflective thinking is an active process valuable in learning and changing behaviors, perspectives, or practices. Nurses can also learn to examine their thinking processes during an interaction as they learn to “think on their feet.” This is a characteristic of expert nurses. As you move from novice to expert, your ability to think critically will improve with practice. In Chapter 6 you read about Dr. Patricia Benner (1984, 1996), who studied the differences in expertise of nurses at different stages in their careers, from novice to expert. So it is with critical thinking: novices think differently from experts. Box 8-3 summarizes the differences in novice and expert thinking. Critical thinking is a complex, purposeful, disciplined process that has specific characteristics that make it different from run-of-the-mill problem solving. Critical thinking in nursing is undergirded by the standards and ethics of the profession. Consciously developed to improve patient outcomes, critical thinking by the nurse is driven by the needs of the patient and family. Nurses who think critically are engaged in a process of constant evaluation, redirection, improvement, and increased efficiency. Be aware that critical thinking involves far more than stating your opinion. You must be able to describe how you came to a conclusion and support your conclusions with explicit data and rationales. Becoming an excellent critical thinker is significantly related to increased years of work experience and to higher education level; moreover, nurses with critical thinking abilities tend to be more competent in their practice than nurses with less well-developed critical thinking skills (Chang, Chang, Kuo et al., 2011). Box 8-4 summarizes these characteristics and offers an opportunity for you to evaluate your progress as a critical thinker. An excellent continuing education (CE) self-study module designed to improve your ability to think critically can be found online (www.nurse.com/ce/CE168-60/Improving-Your-Ability-to-Think-Critically). Continuing one’s education through lifelong learning is an excellent way to maintain and enhance your critical thinking skills. The website www.nurse.com has more than 500 CE opportunities available online and may be helpful to you as you seek to increase your knowledge base and improve your clinical judgment. Being intentional about improving your critical thinking skills ensures that you bring your best effort to the bedside in providing care for your patients. Critical thinking requires systematic and disciplined use of universal intellectual standards (Paul and Elder, 2012). In the practice of nursing, the nursing process represents a universal intellectual standard by which problems are addressed and solved. The nursing process is a method of critical thinking focused on solving patient problems in professional practice. The nursing process is “a conceptual framework that enables the student or the practicing nurse to think systematically and process pertinent information about the patient” (Huckabay, 2009, p. 72). Here is a simple example of how an approved nursing diagnosis may be used: A more detailed discussion of nursing diagnosis is located in the next section of this chapter. The nursing process as a method of clinical problem solving is taught in schools of nursing across the United States, and many states refer to it in their nurse practice acts. The nursing process has sometimes been the subject of criticism among nurses. In recent years, some nursing leaders have questioned the use of the nursing process, describing it as linear, rigid, and mechanistic. They believe that the nursing process contributes to linear thinking and stymies critical thinking. They are concerned that the nursing process format, and rigid faculty adherence to it, encourages students to copy from published sources when writing care plans, thus inhibiting the development of a holistic, creative approach to patient care (Mueller, Johnston, and Bligh, 2002). Certainly the nursing process can be taught, learned, and used in a rigid, mechanistic, and linear manner. Ideally the nursing process is used as a creative approach to thinking and decision making in nursing. Because the nursing process is an integral aspect of nursing education, practice, standards, and practice acts nationwide, learning to use it as a mechanism for critical thinking and as a dynamic and creative approach to patient care is a worthwhile endeavor. Despite reservations among some nurses about its use, the nursing process remains the cornerstone of nursing standards, legal definitions, and practice and, as such, should be well understood by every nurse.
Critical thinking, the nursing process, and clinical judgment
Defining critical thinking
Critical thinking in nursing
The nursing process: An intellectual standard