Individual Psychotherapy
The goal of individual therapy is to alleviate patients’ emotional difficulties in living and the elimination of symptomatology.
Learning objectives
After studying this chapter, you should be able to:
Define the terms transference, countertransference, resistance, and parataxis.
Compare and contrast the principles of individual psychotherapy for children, adolescents, and adults.
Explain the qualifications of a nurse–therapist.
Articulate the role of the nurse as counselor.
Describe some alternate approaches to conventional psychotherapy.
Key Terms
Behavior therapy
Brief cognitive therapy
Brief interpersonal psychotherapy
Cognitive-behavioral therapy
Counseling
Countertransference
Dialectic behavioral therapy
E-therapy
Individual psychotherapy
Parataxis
Psychoanalysis
Psychotherapy
Resistance
Split-treatment psychotherapy
Transference
Psychotherapy has been referred to as the treatment of emotional and personality problems and disorders by psychological means. Many different techniques may be used to treat problems and disorders and to help the client become a mature, satisfied, and independent person. However, an important factor common to all of the techniques is the client–therapist relationship with its interpersonal experiences (Kolb, 1982).
Sigmund Freud (1856–1939) introduced the concept of psychoanalysis, the original talking therapy, which involved analyzing the root causes of behavior and feeling by exploring the unconscious mind and the conscious mind’s relation to it. He was the first to understand and describe the psychotherapeutic process as an interpersonal experience between client and therapist. He thought that our relationships with other people, including clients, are patterned by early infant and childhood relationships with significant people in our environment. These patterns of relationships are repeated later in our lives and may interfere with client–therapist relationships because of transference, or the client’s unconscious assignment to the therapist of feelings and attitudes originally associated with important figures in his or her early life. Transference can be positive (affectionate) or negative (hostile). The therapist, in turn, may exhibit countertransference, or an emotional reaction to the client based on the therapist’s unconscious needs and conflicts. Such a response could interfere with therapeutic interventions during the course of treatment. Resistance, the conscious or unconscious psychological defense against bringing repressed thoughts into conscious awareness, may also occur and interfere with the client’s ability to benefit from psychotherapy. Examples of resistance include remaining silent for a long period of time, being late for a therapy session, or missing appointments (Shahrokh & Hales, 2003; Sadock & Sadock, 2003).
Harry Stack Sullivan, a psychiatrist and psychoanalyst known for his research on the psychotherapy of schizophrenia and for his view of complex interpersonal relationships as the basis of personality development, introduced the term parataxis. It refers to the presence of distorted perception or judgment exhibited by the client during therapy. Parataxis is thought to be the result of earlier experiences in interpersonal relationships and occurs as a defense against anxiety (Shahrokh & Hales, 2003; Fromm-Reichmann, 1960).
According to the American Nurses Association (ANA; 2000), psychotherapy may be performed by the certified specialist in psychiatric–mental health nursing. Psychotherapy may also be performed by licensed clinical social workers, clinical psychologists, and psychiatrists. Psychotherapy is a process in which a person who wishes to relieve symptoms, resolve problems in living, or seek personal growth enters into a contract to interact in a prescribed way with the psychotherapist (Shahrokh & Hales, 2003). Counseling is a form of supportive psychotherapy in which the nurse and other qualified professionals, such as licensed mental health counselors, offer guidance or assist the client in viewing options to problems that are discussed by the client in the context of the nurse–client relationship (ANA, 2000). The psychiatric–mental health nurse must understand these dynamics while using counseling interventions or providing care to clients involved in psychotherapy. Chapter 3 focused on the development of theory-based psychiatric nursing practice and the various roles the nurse serves, including those of therapist and counselor. This chapter focuses on the application of individual therapy and counseling as they relate to the psychological needs of clients, including children and adolescents. Family, couple, and group therapy are addressed in Chapter 15.
Individual Psychotherapy
The principles of psychotherapy are based in part on the application of concepts by Freud and Sullivan. (Box 14-1 summarizes the major schools of psychotherapy). The psychotherapeutic process is designed to bring about understanding of and insight into the historical and dynamic factors that may be unknown to the client and that are among the causes of the mental disturbance for which the client seeks help (Fromm-Reichmann, 1960). Simply put, the main purpose of individual psychotherapy is to gain control of one’s life.
Individual psychotherapy is a confidential relationship between client and therapist that may occur in the therapist’s office, outpatient clinic, or mental hospital. Gender is an important and surprisingly neglected variable in the understanding and practice of psychotherapy. Gender can influence the client’s
choice of therapist, the “fit” between therapist and client, the sequence and content of the clinical material presented, the diagnosis, and the length and outcome of treatment. Age, race, culture, life experiences, and other variables also play an important role in the development of a therapeutic relationship between client and therapist.
choice of therapist, the “fit” between therapist and client, the sequence and content of the clinical material presented, the diagnosis, and the length and outcome of treatment. Age, race, culture, life experiences, and other variables also play an important role in the development of a therapeutic relationship between client and therapist.
Box 14.1: Schools of Psychotherapy
Reconstructive psychotherapy: focuses on emotional and cognitive restructuring of self.
Psychoanalysis (Sigmund Freud): may require several years of therapy and focuses on all aspects of the client’s life
Modifications of psychoanalysis: analytic play therapy (Anna Freud), character analysis (Wilhelm Reich), cognitive analysis (Jean Piaget), existential analysis (Ludwig Binswanger), and transactional analysis (Eric Berne)
Group approaches: psychodrama (J. L. Moreno), psychoanalysis in groups (Alexander Wolf), orthodox psychoanalysis (S. R. Slavson)
Reeducative therapy: focuses on the exploration of new ways of perceiving and behaving (individual or group). Examples include client-centered therapy (Carl Rogers), behavior therapy (Ivan Pavlov, B. E. Skinner, J. B. Watson), and cognitive-behavior therapy (Aaron Beck).
Supportive therapy: focuses on the reinforcement of the client’s self-esteem, ability to adapt, and sense of emotional well-being. Therapy may occur over a brief period or intermittently for years (individual or group). Examples include brief cognitive therapy, brief solution-focused therapy, and bereavement therapy, adaptations of the more coventional modes of therapy.
Edgerton, J. E. & Campbell, R. J. (Eds.). (2003). American psychiatric glossary (7th ed.). Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Press, Inc
;Kolb, L. C. (1982). Modern clinical psychiatry (10th ed.). Philadelphia: W. B. Saunders
; andLego, S. (1996). Psychiatric nursing: A comprehensive reference (2nd ed.). Philadelphia: Lippincott-Raven.
There are three phases of individual psychotherapy: introductory, working, and termination. During the introductory phase, the therapist and client establish boundaries of the relationship. The client’s problems are noted, present coping skills are identified, strengths and attributes are explored, and open communication is established. The working phase occurs when the therapist and client focus on the client’s problems and reach an understanding of why the problems have occurred. Ideally, the termination phase occurs when the client has achieved maximum benefit of therapy. However, termination may occur at any time during the sessions if the client is resistant to treatment or relocation occurs (Lego, 1996).
The goals of individual psychotherapy are to alleviate the client’s discomfort or pain, alter character structure and strengthen the client’s ego, promote emotional and interpersonal maturation, and improve the client’s ability to perform or act appropriately. These goals are achieved by:
Establishing a therapeutic relationship with the client
Providing an opportunity for the client to release tension as problems are discussed
Assisting the client in gaining insight about the problem
Providing the opportunity to practice new skills
Reinforcing appropriate behavior as it occurs
Providing consistent emotional support
If a client is also receiving medication prescribed to stabilize clinical symptoms of a psychiatric disorder (eg, anxiety, depression), the therapist may elect to discuss the efficacy of the medication with the client during a therapy session. Some therapists prefer to treat medication management as a separate entity.
Modes of Individual Psychotherapy
In the past, individual psychotherapy typically involved long-term therapy. However, the advent of managed care has had a profound impact on the practice of psychotherapy. To reduce costs, clients who rely on psychiatric–mental health care benefits are limited to short-term or brief therapy. Brief therapy is a form of psychotherapy that is defined in terms of the number of sessions (generally not more than 15) or in terms of specified objectives that are usually goal-oriented, active, focused, and directed toward a specific problem or symptom (Shahrokh & Hales, 2003). The conventional intensive individual therapies of the past, such as psychoanalysis and uncovering therapy, are being replaced with brief cognitive therapy, behavior therapy, cognitive-behavioral therapy, and brief
interpersonal psychotherapy. A summary of these more commonly used therapies is presented in this chapter. Additionally, Table 14-1 summarizes the other modes of individual psychotherapy such as psychoanalysis, uncovering therapy, hypnotherapy, reality therapy, and rational–emotive therapy, as well the interventions utilized by the nurse therapist.
interpersonal psychotherapy. A summary of these more commonly used therapies is presented in this chapter. Additionally, Table 14-1 summarizes the other modes of individual psychotherapy such as psychoanalysis, uncovering therapy, hypnotherapy, reality therapy, and rational–emotive therapy, as well the interventions utilized by the nurse therapist.
Brief Cognitive Therapy
Brief cognitive therapy uses a time-limited, goal-oriented, problem-solving, here-and-now approach. The therapist assumes an active role while working with individuals to solve present-day problems by identifying distorted thinking that causes emotional discomfort, exploring alternate behaviors, and creating change. There is little emphasis on the cause of the problem. Rather, the client and therapist explore why present thinking is causing the client distress. Candidates for this mode of therapy are described as educated, verbal, and psychologically minded. They are free of borderline personality characteristics (see Chapter 24