Assistive technology: opportunities and implications

CHAPTER 23 Assistive technology


opportunities and implications




FRAMEWORK


It is important to recognise the role of technology and the impact on the lives of people who mostly do not understand how much this technology is already shaping the future.


Older people are often considered unable to learn about new sciences and uninterested in how technology can assist them to live their lives better. This assumption often restricts the use of assistive devices that could be life enhancing. The authors give examples of assistive technology and how it can be applied, both inside and outside the home environment. How to be informed and select the appropriate technology, as well as teaching understanding and acceptance, will be an increasing part of the role of the health care provider. Barriers to the use of assistive technology are discussed and the lack of business models to provide this at reasonable cost to consumers is addressed. The importance of evaluation of the assistive technology is stressed as this becomes the way to determine whether the devices are improving the life of the client or making it more difficult for them to manage. [RN, SG]



Introduction


This chapter seeks to draw together three major issues — the ageing of the population, advances in the use of technology in the care of older people, and the need for evaluation of the impact of this technology within clinical practice.


There is no shortage of data that informs us that we are living longer, and as we get older, we are increasingly living alone and with disabilities. Over the next 40 years, the ageing of the population is projected to slow economic growth at the same time that spending pressures in areas such as health, age pensions, and aged care are projected to rise (Australian Government 2007). The major influence on government spending on aged care is the number of people aged 85 and over and this number is projected to more than quadruple by 2047 (Australian Government 2007). The costs to society are increasing and individuals, families and heath care providers are looking at ways to reduce this burden while maintaining a preferred quality of life.


At the same time we are witnessing a technological revolution. Increasingly, the most innovative uses of technology are taking place in the home. Terms like ‘intelligent home’, ‘smart home’, ‘digital home’ and ‘connected home’ are being used to describe the convergence of a range of technologies and their increased use (Essen & Conrick 2007).


The ageing of the population and improvements in technology are creating a growing interest in the use of technology and its potential role to help support older people to stay independent and in their own homes for as long as possible by service providers, carers and health professionals. Connected home (that is a home with embedded technologies that support independent living and connect to families and carers) and related technologies are increasingly being employed to help older people and people with disabilities to live more independent and productive lives. Such connections also provide benefits beyond the individual and their home. They can assist health care professionals to manage data and improve communication; assist in the monitoring and treatment of chronic conditions; enable the delivering of services beyond the walls of a health institution; and facilitate responses to a critical event (Essen & Conrick 2007).


Assistive technology (AT) can be defined as:




Assistive technology aims to increase the ability of a person to remain independent, reduce risk and maintain engagement in meaningful activities, and includes a wide range of products from simple, low tech and low cost to very technologically complex.




Understanding the role of assistive technology


Control of one’s life, empowerment, integration and full participation in society, independence, autonomy, self-determination, self-respect and self-reliance, as well as participation in diagnosis, treatment and decisions about care, all relate in one way or another to the concept of human dignity (Comyn et al 2006).


Assistive technology may contribute to the maintenance of human dignity as people get older, and older people often have decreased functional capacity resulting from increased frailty and/or decreasing cognitive ability. One solution is to offer assistance through technology in the form of a range of equipment or devices to enhance their living environment, thus extending their ability to operate effectively in the face of decreasing functional capacity.


The application of AT should therefore aim to:






Intrusive technologies or functions, such as location and monitoring, can be of concern as is the potential for social isolation if technologies substitute human caring. Privacy and confidentiality are critical factors in acceptance of AT. Trust established between practitioner and consumer will assist individuals to see the benefit of data collection and, with appropriate guidelines, the value of sharing data and experiences with others. Anxiety around the perception of ‘being watched’ by the use of electronic devices is understandable. Surveillance is an uncomfortable concept for most people, particularly someone who is feeling vulnerable or at risk. Careful explanation, clear policies and procedures, rigorous monitoring and regular feedback can all facilitate understanding and acceptance. Engagement of the consumer in the selection, establishment and implementation of any AT will encourage acceptance and minimise anxiety.




Categories and approaches across the sector



The role of technology


In the future we can expect that technology will transform ageing and aged care just as it has done for other industries and other aspects of our lives. It will allow greater choice including remaining safe and healthy in our own homes and delaying or avoiding a move to institutional care, and choosing to remain socially connected and active.


Philipson & Roberts (2007) identified four key areas where digital technologies can be used to improve the lives of the aged, disabled and chronically ill. These include: self-management of health care in home settings with potential savings and other benefits; home automation, which will enhance security, safety and independence at home, and will help maintain quality of life and decrease the demand for carer support hours; communication technologies, which will provide important benefits for people whose mobility is limited, or who live alone; and finally, the various home automation and digital technologies can benefit the aged and the disabled, improving their quality of life by enhancing their independence. Technology has the potential to extend the physical independence of the aged, so they can stay for longer in their homes. It gives them a more dignified life, and it saves public and private money.


When we consider how pervasive computer controls are in modern cars or aircraft it is perhaps surprising that computer-aided technology is not already more readily available in our own homes. Cars commonly contain many intelligent controls for security, engines and braking. Displays can show global positioning, fuel consumption, distance calculation and can provide cameras or alerts to assist in reversing or parking. All doors can be locked remotely with a single press of a button and the car itself can turn off all interior and external lights. Much of the technology in cars has come from the highly sophisticated aviation industry.


There has also been increasing use of intelligent controls engineered into modern buildings. This includes smoke detectors linked to the building fire sprinkler systems. The elevators are often remotely monitored. Closed Circuit Television (CCTV) for security is ubiquitous in commercial and public places. The Department of Health in Queensland, Australia, has begun installing intelligent controls with remote monitoring for some of its hospitals. These control, for example, hot water systems that can monitor use and then reduce energy-consumption according to demand. Knowing the periods of peak demand allows scheduling the boilers to prepare in advance. These kinds of controls applied to heating, lighting, air-conditioning and other services can learn patterns of use and reduce energy consumption at quiet times and build up in preparation for periods of peak demand.


The use of technology within the home however is not so far advanced. Currently all doors, windows, curtains and light switches need to be operated individually. If we go out and forget to lock the doors there is no embedded intelligence that would recognise the house is vacant and turn off lights and lock doors in the way some modern cars can. Heating, lighting and air-conditioning systems cannot track the movements and numbers of people between rooms and ramp services up or down according to need.




Selection of assistive technologies


Whilst there are many examples of AT in use there is also a high rate of abandonment of existing AT (Reimer-Reiss & Wacker 2000). There is little research into the reasons for abandonment, however Reimer-Reiss and Wacker (2000) recommend that users be involved in any decisions on AT that they are expected to use. It will be important to learn from experiences in use of non-intelligent technologies in planning for the evaluation and adoption of intelligent AT. Issues to consider include: the availability of support for the technology; any stigma or embarrassment about its use; availability of people to respond to alerts such as a professional call centre or family carer; whether the potential user has been directly involved in the acquisition; whether it fits conveniently into the living arrangements of the user; and whether our care organisations are ready for the work practice and care model changes that may be necessary for adoption of the technology and realisation of the benefits. Older persons’ accommodation can be quite small and limit the introduction of, for example, lift chairs.



When considering the selection and implementation of AT one may be confronted by a plethora of vendor claims and glossy brochures for their products. To facilitate more judicious choices, particularly for care provider organisations, the following steps are suggested.




Understanding and acceptance


Technology is now playing an important role in maintaining independent living, linking health services, housing, social care and community safety. For the individual, the benefits cited include improved quality of life, reduced emergency admissions for acute events, and reduced lengths of stay, particularly for those with long-term conditions. For family carers the benefit includes support to enable them to provide care at home for as long as possible.



For the individual


Assistive technology products can support self-care, enable an individual to accomplish daily living tasks, assist them in communication, work or recreation activities and help them to achieve a level of independence that is necessary for them to remain outside of an institutional care environment.


There is growing evidence to show that supporting self-care leads to a number of positive outcomes:





Assistive technology can be useful for someone who is finding basic household chores difficult or impossible, or who is anxious about their ability to remember events and activities. It is also useful for family members who need to maintain regular contact to ‘monitor’ heath status, security and safety of the individual who is living alone.



Communication is particularly important for someone who has limited mobility, cognitive impairment or who lives a long way from family and/or friends. Assistive technology can provide many different ways for an individual to communicate, to maintain social networks, and to transmit and receive information. Family members and health professionals can monitor health and wellbeing daily and initiate intervention when necessary. Assistive technology can manage the risks associated with living alone as well as monitor lifestyle changes or changes in regular behaviour. Individuals report that they feel better because they can manage their symptoms and respond to changes with, for example, pain management, anxiety and depression.


The following vignettes provide examples of how AT devices can assist an individual who is living at home to manage their situation and monitor their health status.



Carers are usually partners or other family members. Their responsibilities for the dependent person can severely restrict their own activities. They may be unable to leave the dependent person alone if they are prone to wandering, falling or putting themselves at risk in other ways. As a consequence, they can become isolated. Carers often neglect their own nutritional needs and other aspects of their health as they may be too tired to prepare their own meals. They may also be at risk of injury through lifting the dependent person and assisting them in slippery areas like bathrooms.


Caring for someone with cognitive impairment can be particularly stressful. The need to give someone repeated reminders about activities of daily living (ADL) can be frustrating. The technology that can assist with providing reminders will never become stressed or frustrated. Carers can also use telehealth technology to assist in maintaining their own health as well as that of the person they are supporting.



Examples of AT that may assist the individual are outlined below.





Robots


Robots perform much of the work in manufacturing, including automobile assembly. Work has been underway for many years to build a humanoid robot personal assistant or carer. Honda’s Asimo robot may be the most advanced to date and suggests that a robot assistant in homes may not be far off (http://asimo.honda.com/). In France, the Alcatel-Lucent research laboratory has enhanced Sony’s Aibo robot dog so that it can continuously monitor a person’s safety and wellbeing (Gass & Hill 2007) and become a personal carer. The dog has a camera, microphone and wireless connection. It can provide reminders and alerts and through pattern recognition it will know its owner. If, for example, a carer was unable to contact an older person, the dog could be contacted and could search for its owner. The carer could see through the dog’s camera ‘eyes’. REVES (Robot visant à Embellir la Vie des Enfants en chambre Stérile) was originally designed as a robot companion for children in hospital and particularly for those in isolation rooms. The robot dog would provide a companion to an isolated child patient as well as a multimedia terminal complete with camera, microphone, loudspeaker, gaming and links to clinicians, friends and family that the child could use (Gass & Hill 2007). The potential for similar use in the care of older people is obvious.


There have been other developments of robots as media for telehealth or teleconsultations with clinicians. In 2004, a prototype known as Roy the Robot was built at the Centre for Online Health at the University of Queensland in Australia to support Gladstone Hospital, which is about 500 km north of Brisbane. At the time, there was no full-time paediatrician on staff, despite the hospital having a paediatric ward. The robot provided a link with a specialist in Brisbane who could make a virtual ward round.


Queensland is the largest state in Australia with enormous distances between cities, regional and rural centres. The majority of rural hospitals and some regional hospitals lack staff specialists, and telehealth can provide support for local clinicians in remote locations as well as direct patient consultations. The technology can also be used for training of registrars and other staff. To date, few health care payers or insurers will fund electronic or telehealth consultations. A challenge for research is to demonstrate the benefits and to develop the new models of care delivered through intelligent technology.


Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Dec 10, 2016 | Posted by in NURSING | Comments Off on Assistive technology: opportunities and implications

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access