Chapter Fifteen. Specialist community public health nurse
Health visiting
Dianne Watkins and Lorraine Joomun
KEY ISSUES
• History and development of health visiting
• Current specialist community public health nursing professional practice and the principles of health visiting
• Family health visiting
• The specialist community public health nurse: health visitors’ role in safeguarding children
• Emerging opportunities for specialist community public health nurse: health visitors in public health
Introduction
The 21st century provides opportunities for specialist community public health nursing, health visiting, to reaffirm its public health role and make an active and visible contribution to meeting the public health agenda in the United Kingdom. Health visiting has always been firmly rooted in promoting the health of the public with a particular emphasis on maternal and child health (Council for the Education and Training of Health Visitors (CETHV) 1977). However, a more interprofessional approach to public health is now required to address the gross inequalities in health between social groups in society and to work in a proactive manner. This ideology is clearly directed by government policy in the present-day National Health Service (NHS) (Department of Health, 1989, Department of Health, 1999a, Department of Health, 2001, Department of Health, 2003a, Department of Health, 2003b, Department of Health, 2004a, Department of Health, 2004b and Department of Health, 2007, Home Office, 1998 and Home Office, 1999, SNMAC 1995, Welsh Assembly Government, 2005a and Welsh Assembly Government, 2005b, Welsh Office, 1998a, Welsh Office, 1998b and Welsh Office, 1999) and in the past history of the development of health visiting (CETHV 1977, Ministry of Health 1948).
Health visiting encompasses an individualistic and a structuralist approach to its work that seeks to empower individuals and communities to achieve their full potential for the achievement of health, through actions directed at biological, socio-economic, lifestyle and environmental determinants of health. The focus of practice is the promotion of health and well-being, protection and prevention (Nursing and Midwifery Council (NMC) 2004). The contribution of health visiting to the public health agenda has been reaffirmed by the House of Commons Health Committee (2001) and is further supported by the Royal College of General Practitioners (RCGP; 2001). They are considered ‘major contributors to improving health and to the broader social inclusion agenda’ (United Kingdom Central Council for Nursing, Midwifery and Health Visiting (UKCC) 2001: 2) and a key resource on public health issues in the community (House of Commons Health Committee 2001).
This chapter will provide a brief overview of the history of the profession and discuss the origin of the current specialist community public health nurse, the health visitor’s role in public health, maternal and child health, and the protection of children under the age of 5 years in the United Kingdom. It will briefly explore the concept of public health, with an emphasis on health visitors’ work in relation to primary, secondary and tertiary prevention. The chapter will conclude with identifying the emerging opportunities for health visitors to expand their public health role, discussed in the context of current health and social policies. It is important to note that although health visitors are renamed specialist community public health nurses, at this present time they are still annotated on the register as health visitors. Therefore to avoid confusion they will be referred to as health visitors throughout this chapter.
Historical perspective
The origins of health visiting practice began in 1862 with the formation of the Manchester and Salford Ladies Sanitary Reform Association. Respectable women were appointed to ‘teach hygiene and social welfare, give social support and teach mental and moral health’ (Robinson 1982). The notion of household hygiene was one echoed by Florence Nightingale; even in those early days of nursing she recognized the link between child mortality and cleanliness:
The same laws of health or of nursing, for they are in reality the same, obtain among the well as among the sick. The causes of the enormous child mortality are perfectly well known, they are chiefly want of cleanliness, want of ventilation, careless dieting and clothing, want of whitewashing; in one word defective household hygiene. (Florence Nightingale 1858 cited inCETHV 1977: 12)
Although Florence Nightingale felt this was a call to the nursing profession, she was able to make the division between nursing the sick and nursing the well. She acknowledged the importance of a ‘non-judgemental’ home visiting service, which would prevent the service becoming unpopular or seen as interference in the lives of families (CETHV 1977: 12). In 1892 the first health visiting training programme was established. However, it was not formally recognized as such until 1919 when the Ministry of Health and the Board of Education jointly validated a 2-year course of study.
During these early years of health visiting, the emphasis was on promoting public health, through teaching and helping the poor, with activities more related to social work, and improving sanitary conditions, than it was to nursing. However, the importance of maternal and child health grew, influenced by the many recruits to the Boer War who were unfit for military service. This led to a realization that investing in the health of children was important for the economy and productivity of the country, and consequently the infant welfare movement emerged. Clinics were established to teach mothers how to care for their babies, and in 1925 the Ministry of Health recommended that all health visitors possess a midwifery qualification. This was influential in promoting the health visitors’ role in working primarily with mothers and children, and health visiting became a universal home visiting service extended to middle class families.
The health visitor’s work continued to retain a child and maternal health perspective. However, it also focused on the field of social medicine and the numbers of health visitors were increased in an effort to reduce child mortality and morbidity. There was a fall in maternal and child mortality between 1901 and 1971, which can be attributed in part to improved maternal nutrition, legal abortion, extending the period of breastfeeding, and improved living conditions. Although medical advances, such as immunization and antibiotics, made some contribution to improving the health of the nation, this was considered small in comparison with the impact of efforts to improve environmental and social conditions (Ashton and Seymour 1988). As the health of mothers and children improved, so the need for health visitors appeared to decline. However, Beveridge (Ministry of Health 1948) reinstated the role which reinforced the maternal and child health component, and also widened the scope of the health visitor’s work. The NHS Act (Ministry of Health 1948) defined health visitors as:
Women employed by local authority for visiting persons in their homes for the purpose of giving advice as to the care of young children, persons suffering from illness, and expectant and nursing mothers, and as to the measures necessary to prevent the spread of infection. (Wilkie 1979)
Although the focus was primarily mothers and young children, the scope of health visiting practice expanded during the early years of the NHS in an attempt to meet the above description of the role. This led to some difficulties in health visitors clearly defining their work and disparities were evident throughout the UK. Some health visitors were ‘triple duty’ nurses engaged in health visiting, district nursing and midwifery duties, others were working directly in the school health service and some were working with the elderly or diabetics (CETHV 1977).
As a result of the inequities in service delivery and poor recruitment to health visiting training, an investigation was commissioned. The Jameson Report (Ministry of Health 1956) was published as a result of this investigation, which advocated a number of changes for the profession. It stated that health visitors must retain their focus with families where there were young children. However, they should become family visitors with a primary function of social advice and health education.
Present-day specialist community public health nursing: health visiting practice
In 1962 the Health Visiting and Social Work Act set up the Council for the Training of Health Visitors (later known as the Council for the Education and Training of Health Visitors (CETHV)). They offer the following definition for health visiting:
the professional practice of health visiting consists of planned activities aimed at the promotion of health and prevention of ill health. It therefore contributes substantially to individual and social well-being, by focussing attention at various times on either an individual, a social group or a community. (CETHV 1977: 8)
This definition is one that is still used today and it outlines the complex nature of health visiting, in that the focus for promoting health is not just the individual, i.e. the child, mother or family, but also social groups and communities. Health visitors assess the health needs of community populations, groups and individuals and establish appropriate programmes of prevention which contribute to social well-being, as well as physical and emotional health (Nursing and Midwifery Council, 2002 and Nursing and Midwifery Council, 2004, Quality Assurance Agency for Higher Education (QAA) 2001, UKCC 2001). Health visiting differs from other dimensions of nursing because of its emphasis on working with communities to address issues of health and social inequalities and social exclusion (see Chapter 23 for further information). This dimension of their work clearly fits into the remit of public health, although it is different from other professionals who practise within this field. Health visitors usually hold a caseload made up of individual clients who are either registered with a general practitioner to whom the health visitor is attached, or make up a defined community, allocated to them on a geographical basis. This allows for personal individual contact, as well as opportunities to work on public health issues with specific groups and communities, such as Sure Start and Flying Start.
In 2004 the NMC made changes to the current register, with the formation of three registers, one each for nursing, midwifery and specialist community public health nursing. All health visitors were migrated to this register. The formation and naming of this register had implications for health visiting, in light of the name change and protection of the public. Standards of proficiency for specialist community public health nursing were developed by the NMC in 2004. These standards also incorporated school nursing and occupational health nursing. All three disciplines were registered on the third register under the title ‘Specialist Community Public Health Nurse’. Each discipline would be annotated on the register according to the route that was undertaken within an educational programme. New educational programmes were designed to meet this new structure.
The public health role of the health visitor
Public health has been defined as ‘the science and art of preventing disease, prolonging life and promoting health through organized efforts and informed choices of society, organizations, public and private, communities and individuals’ (Wanless 2004: 27). The science and art of preventing disease in health visiting practice has been described by Twinn (1991), who discusses how health visitors combine a scientific approach with the art of health visiting. The scientific basis to their work encapsulates epidemiology, and the evidence base for practice is extracted from research. This is combined with the art of professional judgement based on intuition, the complexities of families and communities, past experiences and the unique situations health visitors find themselves in. There is an art in synthesizing this information, reflecting on and in action and understanding and helping clients to achieve health. Health visiting as previously mentioned is also concerned with ‘planned activities aimed at the promotion of health and prevention of ill health’ (CETHV 1977), which has a positive effect on the health of individuals and society.
The public health role of the health visitor is reaffirmed by the NMC in its standards of proficiency for specialist community public health nursing when ‘health visiting’ was renamed ‘SCPHN’ (NMC 2004). This is further supported by the QAA, who developed ‘benchmarking standards for health visiting education and practice’ that clearly articulate the public health dimension of their work (QAA 2001). The latter document uses the following health visiting principles developed in 1977 (CETHV 1977) to underpin professional practice, which provide a sound basis for public health and are now firmly rooted in research. The NMC adopted these principles and adapted them to support their standards for practice (CETHV 1977: 9, Cowley, Appleton, 2000 and Cowley, Appleton, 2000, Cowley, Frost, 2006 and Cowley, Frost, 2006, Twinn and Cowley 1992):
1. The search for health needs.
2. The stimulation of an awareness of health needs.
3. The influence on policies affecting health.
4. The facilitation of health-enhancing activities.
Sharon is a single parent with two children under 3 years. She lives in rented accommodation on a deprived housing estate. Sharon has recently moved to the area. There is a lack of provision and a shop that sells a small variety of groceries is available. The area is particularly run down, with graffiti over the walls and burnt out cars in the streets.
Q. What knowledge and skills do you have that could identify the immediate needs of this family?
The search for health needs
One of the unique functions of health visiting is searching for health needs, some of which may be self-declared by individuals or communities, while others may be unrecognized and require skill by the health visitor to identify. This search, or proactive investigation, is essential before an assessment of health needs and planning to meet these can take place. It is working at this stage of ‘pre-need’ when trying to prevent needs arising in relation to social and health issues (Standing Nursing and Midwifery Advisory Committee (SNMAC) 1995) that makes health visiting practice different to any other health professional working within primary or community care and also adds to the complexities of measuring the effectiveness of their practice (Campbell et al 1995, McHugh and Luker 2002). The universal nature of the health visiting service places health visitors in an excellent position to identify the wider needs (Cowley, Frost, 2006 and Cowley, Frost, 2006) which may otherwise have remained suppressed or concealed. Some examples of this work include detecting and working effectively with women suffering postnatal depression (MacInnes 2000), working with children and families ‘in need’ and identification of child neglect or abuse (Appleton and Clemerson 1999), identifying and working with parents on child-feeding issues, nutrition, behavioural or sleep problems, all of which affect child and family health (Acheson, 1998 and Acheson, 1998, Olds et al 1997, Seeley et al 1996).
Health visitors are also concerned with the broader issues that influence health, for example poverty, housing, unemployment and infrastructures supporting communities, such as public transport. A more recent finding is the effect that ‘place’ has on health improvement (Popay et al 2003). The search for health needs involves looking at these external factors that affect health, which individuals ultimately may have little control over, and working at a political level to try to positively influence these issues (see Chapter 7 for further information).
The work of health visitors in searching for health needs in communities primarily revolves around creating a profile of the local community that takes cognizance of epidemiological data, local information, community and individual needs (see Chapter 6 for further information on health needs assessment). This information is used to inform the Health Improvement Programme (HImP) for that area and ultimately to influence resource allocation (United Kingdom Standing Conference for Health Visiting Education (UKSC) 2001). Sharing of information especially in safeguarding children is an important part of this process and the common assessment frameworks (CAF) have been identified in searching for these health needs.
Sharon is socially isolated, lacking friends or family in the vicinity; she only goes out to the local shop when necessary, and she is fearful of some of the local youths that hang around. The children are kept inside and they never socialize with other children. Sharon is finding it difficult to cope, especially as the older child is displaying behaviour problems.
Q. What knowledge do you have of the local community and what services are on offer for families?
The stimulation of an awareness of health needs
The stimulation of an awareness of health needs refers to helping people become aware of what may be possible to achieve in an effort to improve their personal health, or the health of the community (CETHV 1977, Twinn and Cowley 1992, UKSC 2001). This can also include working with disadvantaged groups in society who may have limited access to health information and resources (QAA 2001, UKSC 2001). Cowley, Frost, 2006 and Cowley, Frost, 2006 suggest that stimulating an awareness of health needs should be extended to three different levels:
• to clients, individuals and communities
• to those who take responsibility for the commissioning of health services (health authorities, primary care trusts, local health boards)
• to politicians and policy makers.
In working with all of the above groups, the health visitor may stimulate an awareness of health needs through the provision of knowledge, recognizing that the way in which this is delivered is dependent upon the situation. When working with individuals and communities it is essential to take cognizance of social, educational and cultural backgrounds and people’s personal experiences, and consider how they affect individual perceptions of health. Empowering individuals and communities to gain control over factors that influence their health underpins the application of this health visiting principle in practice and demonstrates the approach used by health visitors when engaging in ‘health promotion’ as seen in its broadest sense. This is encapsulated in the definition given by the World Health Organization (1986), which states that ‘health promotion is about enabling people to increase control over and so improve their health’. The QAA (2001: 7) emphasizes this point when it describes health visiting as using a ‘partnership approach to practice, through which clients are empowered to address issues influencing their health’. This is an essential element of promoting health and preventing ill health and places health visitors in a central position to deliver a public health agenda, based on identified health needs.
It is worth exploring ‘empowerment’ in more detail in an effort to describe the way in which health visitors undertake practice. Empowerment is a two-way process between professional and client, where the client’s needs take priority, and goals are negotiated (Naidoo and Wills 2000). The principles revolve around fostering informed choice, supporting change rather than coercing clients, the provision of knowledge and allowing people to make up their own mind (Tones and Tilford 1994: 11). Persuasion, instruction or propaganda do not form part of the process; however, clarifying values, building self-esteem, and developing supportive environments and services to achieve well-being are essential ingredients of this approach (Cowley, Frost, 2006 and Cowley, Frost, 2006). It is important to consider that some families lead complex and deprived lives; these often hard to reach families have hidden needs which can be identified by the health visitor.
When working with politicians and policy makers to stimulate an awareness of health needs it is essential to ensure that links, whether overt or covert, are made with the political agenda. To inform this process health visitors need to ensure that health profiles are compiled based on epidemiological data and client experiences, and clearly identify the issues for the community, such as housing or safe play areas for children. Action taken to improve communities must be undertaken in partnership with other agencies, as no one agency can be effective alone.
Sharon’s accommodation consists of a flat on the third floor; she has no garden for the children to play in, and there are no park facilities in the neighbourhood.
Q. What specialist skills and knowledge do you have to influence the local authority in developing safe play areas for children?
The influence on policies affecting health
Cowley, Frost, 2006 and Cowley, Frost, 2006: 32) suggest that this principle can be implemented through three interwoven mechanisms:
• information/health intelligence
• innovation and change within the NHS/health sector
• acting as a resource.
Health visitors influence policies on a national and local level and this is pivotal to promoting health and preventing ill health (QAA 2001, UKSC 2001). They are ideally placed in the heart of the community to identify health and social needs, by identifying problems early, and to develop policies to prevent these problems (Wanless 2004). Information about emerging health needs in the community should be disseminated to health commissioners; health visitors collate such information, and therefore it would make sense for health visitors to become actively involved in primary care trusts or local health boards to influence healthcare planning based on accurate needs assessments, ensuring that strategies include issues for prevention (SNMAC 1995). This would incorporate taking part in strategy development that may impact on the health of the community. Examples relate to influencing health improvement plans, health action zones (HAZs) or contributing to services in relation to healthy living centres. Working at an international and a national level with organizations such as the Community Practitioner and Health Visitor Association and the Royal College of Nursing is an effective way to influence policy development and the future profession of health visiting.
Sharon and the children would benefit from groups and activities that would enable her to meet people and socialize her and the children into the community.
Q. What knowledge and skills do you have that could be used to develop interventions to address the needs for this family?
The facilitation of health-enhancing activities
Facilitating health-enhancing activities is a major part of health visiting professional practice and includes the broad remit of public health inclusive of environmental changes, personal preventative activities and therapeutic endeavours (Cowley, Frost, 2006 and Cowley, Frost, 2006). This may take place through encouraging and enabling individuals to take responsibility for their own health, through facilitating health-enhancing activities which could be community or family based, or by influencing policy formation which positively affects health. Campaigning to establish services in deprived or disadvantaged areas such as nursery school provision, or activities for teenagers are examples of facilitating health-enhancing activities. Monitoring health needs and acting as an agent who mediates between agencies on behalf of families and individuals and promotes health-enhancing activities is another element of health visiting.
Sure Start, and more recently Flying Start, is the cornerstone of the government’s drive to tackle child poverty and social exclusion (Home Office 1998, Welsh Office 1999, Welsh Assembly Government 2005b), and provides excellent examples of health-enhancing activities by health visitors (Bidmead 1999, Daniel 1999). There is substantial evidence to support early interventions with children and much of the work in the United States by Olds, Henderson, Chamberlin, Tatenbaum, 1986 and Olds et al, 1997 and Kitzman et al (1997) demonstrated the benefits of home visiting in the pre- and postnatal period. The results of these studies indicate programmes can reduce child abuse and neglect, improve parenting skills and the quality of child interactions, reduce subsequent pregnancies and, in the long term, reduce criminal behaviour of mothers and children (Olds et al 1998). This evidence base has been used as the basis for Sure Start programmes, which are multiagency and set about to improve the health, intellectual and social development of children; pilot sites have been set up in England to implement parenting programmes using the Olds methods (Home Office, 1998 and Home Office, 1999).