Respect: The Difference It Makes



Respect


The Difference It Makes



When I was small, there was a week when the whole country knew that every human life is irreplaceable. It was many years ago, but, as I recall, a child somewhere in the Midwest fell down an abandoned well, and for a week rescue teams worked to bring her out. This was a time before television, and radios were playing everywhere—in the stores, in the buses, even at school. Strangers met in the street and asked each other, “any news”? People of all religions prayed together.


As the rescue effort went on, no one asked if that was the child of a professor down there, the child of a cleaning woman, the child of a wealthy family. Was that child black, white, or yellow? Was that child good or naughty, smart or slow? In that week everyone knew that these things did not matter at all. That the importance of a child’s life had nothing to do with those things. A person lost touched us all, diminished us all.


R.N. Remen1


Chapter Objectives


The reader will be able to:



Chances are you do not recall where you first encountered the idea that there is something about human beings that commands our attention and respect, something that goes beyond the differences that sometimes tend to separate us. The physician who wrote the above quote about her childhood experience goes on to say that this experience was important because, as she would learn later, the idea that persons have a basic human dignity deserving of respect is at the heart of the health professional and patient relationship.


To get you started on your exploration of respect as it is expressed in your professional encounters, consider the picture of this health professional and a patient (Figure 1-1).




You may see other features of this relationship that suggest the health professional basically respects this patient.


Whether you are preparing to enter a profession for the first time or are continuing to seek excellence in it through further study, being able to show and receive respect is a key to the satisfaction you will be able to realize over the course of your career as a professional. You might, in fact, think of respect as a linchpin that holds together your professional identity. Without respect for (and from) others you will almost inevitably find the paths you are choosing in your professional life to be veering off course.


What Is Respect?


Respect comes from the Latin root respicere, which means “to look at closely.” In common parlance it has come to be interpreted as approaching a person, group, idea, or object with regard or esteem.2 It says, “you matter,” “you are worth the trouble.” No matter how extreme our circumstances, we as humans hope that others will not discount our need to be somebody, that we will be sympathetically accompanied through the most difficult and unlikable or threatening aspects of our struggles. And when we rejoice, we hope others will join us in our celebration of accomplishment. In other words, we count on others’ respect for who we are in a very fundamental sense that we all are humans. Many writers who have tried to explain that humans have basic worth agree that we share a common essence, which they term dignity. Even the ancients, in their myths, described this common essence, a theme also explored in virtually all the world’s major religious traditions.3 The essence is often referred to as the inherent dignity of persons to help emphasize that it resides beyond the physical, social, or psychological characteristics that distinguish us from each other.4


Inherent dignity is deeply ingrained into the idea of a profession. There have been centuries of attempts to fully explain it, an exploration that continues to this day on the assumption that there is a common thread of humanity that warrants basic regard of a person as such, no matter the variations that distinguishes him or her from others. In your study of this textbook we will help you look for specific expressions of respect through such everyday actions as the tone of your voice when you address a patient, the adaptation of your pace and body language to meet the needs of a child versus an elderly patient, your trustworthy keeping of a patient confidence, your attention to cultural differences, your presence during a crisis, and your willingness to work together with a patient’s family and other professionals to reach his or her personal health-related goal.


In the health care setting your show of respect is a response to the fact that patients are vulnerable in ways that do not exist outside of the health care context but they also remain able to participate in decisions directly (or sometimes through a surrogate voice) that protect meaning in their life. Therefore, if you value respect, you will want to protect patients from exploitation or harm and advocate for them in ways that will be to their benefit. A helpful concept to help you understand the deeper relational dynamics that are taking place in respectful communications is care.


Respect and Care


Everyone talks about care as a positive feature of human relationships. It is. But care has a much more serious function in sustaining them than we often acknowledge. It is the link we make with another human being in distress, taking their suffering and well-being into account. Reich associates true caring with what we decide to do in a relationship when the chips are down.6 Often it is not limited to the warm sentimentality so often expressed on the inside of greeting cards. True caring requires us to choose among our priorities and may become a challenge or even a burden. Our lives and energies are expended on what in reality we care about or value, no matter what we may say to the contrary.6 This is precisely what distinguishes sentimentality from a motivation to care: Sentimentality stresses the awareness that you feel an emotion which evokes something in you to respond, whereas caring always requires involved concern about the specific barriers to a person’s well-being and the action required to relieve them. We introduce it here because it helps to connect the idea of respect more generally with how our actions are outgrowths of core values we hold and are expressed in our roles as a person, professional, and member of society.


Respect and Your Values


Values describe things we hold dear. We say that something is “of value” when we estimate it to be of worth or usefulness to us for an important end. Values can include ideals, principles, attitudes, or actions and are treasured for their power to provide a spiritual, moral, or practical compass for leading a good life and to help us understand what will give life its meaning. Some values are presented as aspirations or duties. Other values are dispositions or traits of character such as love, compassion, honesty, generosity, faithfulness, or a sense of adventure. Yet other values are in the form of rituals or everyday practices and may include leisure, worship, work, and a myriad of other ways we choose to spend our time and energies. Finally, we value objects, too, for their usefulness, beauty, or power to evoke memory or meaning. One criterion of a “true” value is that it has become part of a pattern of a person’s life.


Taken together, your values constitute your value system. Some values in that system are highly specific to you. Some will be adopted through your cultural and/or professional subgroup. Still others are shared by humans because of our common “human condition.” The unique value system for each person creates a profile of his or her idea of “the good life.”


Personal Values


Personal values are strictly one’s own. We learn our early values from parents and other childhood friends, caregivers, teachers, religious beliefs and traditions, and cultural influences such as TV and the Internet. Values are imparted, taught, reinforced, and internalized. We incorporate many of them into our lives as a personal value system. We also exist in a complex world of bureaucracies and institutions. These influence us, too, so that as we mature our values evolve with us.


Most people cherish more than one personal good, or value. Literature provides striking examples of the exception: Ahab braved the high seas relishing the thought of getting revenge on the great white whale, Moby Dick; Sir Lancelot suffered many grave adversities in his relentless quest for the Holy Grail; and, before his change of heart, Ebenezer Scrooge treasured money. The narrow scope of personal values of Ahabs, Sir Lancelots, and Scrooges are exceptions. Most people have many personal values, some more clearly defined than others, and go through life trying to realize or balance several values simultaneously.


The process of developing self-consciousness about one’s values is the focus of values clarification exercises. Values clarification provides the means to discover what values we live by. An individual who can identify his or her own values is able to place worth on actions or objects that lead to personally satisfying choices. Conversely, if unclear about our values or the connection between values and choices, it is likely that there will be poor decision-making and dissatisfaction.7



image REFLECTIONS


The following values clarification exercise is helpful in identifying personal values and how these values play out in real life.


First, make a list of your 10 most important present values in order of importance.


Next, compare and contrast your own list of personal values with peers’ values.


Then, compare the list of your own highest-ranking values with your own behavior.


To what degree is your behavior consistent with your stated values? If there is an inconsistency, why?


What can you go do (if anything) to get your stated values and behaviors in closer alignment?


As we suggested, sometimes your personal values will conflict with each other. An example is the case of a man who is excessively obese. Although there are many factors contributing to obesity, consider the obese person who finds security in consuming food. Unfortunately, his habitual eating eventually causes his body to break down, and his physician tells him that he can expect a shortened life span. At this point his basic value of life itself is endangered by the competing personal value of feeling secure. Because both of these values are essential to good health, treatment often is directed toward helping this person derive security from aspects of life other than eating. Similar examples of clashing values surround challenges related to other life-endangering practices, such as smoking, substance abuse, or lack of exercise or good sleeping habits.



image REFLECTIONS


Your choice to make a career in the health professions has come from a desire to act on some of your most cherished values. Can you name some personal values that you recognize as consistent with your commitment to becoming and being a good health professional?

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Apr 10, 2017 | Posted by in NURSING | Comments Off on Respect: The Difference It Makes

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access