13.1 In or out-patients from your hospital or health care unit
In some respects, recruiting from within the health care system is easier and less daunting than going out into the outside world and trying to find the right people. At least there are specific points of contact where people can be located, such as wards and out-patient clinics.
If you intend to recruit from wards or specific clinics you should first write to all the consultants whose patients may be involved to ask for their support and permission to approach their patients. This is a matter of courtesy and you should not expect any major objections if you have all the appropriate approvals.
13.1.1 Recruiting from out-patient clinics
In this context out-patient clinics include clinics in hospitals, GP practices, health centres or any site where health care clinics operate. You should always start by discussing the study with the person in charge of the clinic and the other staff who work there. They will need to know your inclusion and exclusion criteria so they can refer possible patients to you. These are very busy people and so you will need to make this decision process as easy as possible. For example, provide a simple summary of your criteria as a poster that can be pinned in front of the desk. If you have a long list of criteria only include the ones that concern their ability to refer you suitable patients, you can then check the other details. If you look at Figure 12.1 (p 120), the screening form lists numerous criteria, but my simplified version for the clinic only included patients with chronic respiratory disease, aged over 65 years and with recent weight loss or body mass index less than or equal to 20.
Clinic nurses can be great supporters of research work and they may also be asked to refer suitable patients, bleep or phone you so you can rush up and see patients, or generally just introduce the idea of the research to patients as they assess them.
If you work and treat patients in the clinic from which you intend to recruit, your job will be much easier. You will know the staff and the clinic process, and be able to access patients’ notes to screen for suitable participants. If you do not routinely work in the clinic it is a good idea to be present whenever you are able. Patients can see you immediately, your presence will remind other staff to refer patients to you, and you can spend time chatting to suitable patients about the research. No one will explain and promote your research as well as you will. You will also be able to undertake any preliminary screening to make sure patients are eligible, provide patient information sheets and consent forms, and arrange follow-up phone calls to see if the patient does wish to participate.
You can also appeal to the clinic patients directly by using an advert or poster, giving brief details about the study, and a contact name and number to call if they are interested. Always try to include a benefit for the volunteers to take part in the study, for example, they get their cholesterol checked, they get the chance to discuss their experiences and opinions, or they may receive an intervention that may improve their health. If you are at a loss to find any particular benefit to the individual you can say they will be helping improve future patient care. Any posters or adverts aimed at research volunteers must be approved by the ethics committee, so if you didn’t include a poster in your original application you must submit an amendment and get the wording and design approved.
If you know exactly what type of patient you are looking for (for example diabetic patients aged over 60 years) another strategy may be to search the clinic appointment lists on the hospital information system. You can then identify the people in the appropriate age range and send them the information on your study. Due to patient confidentiality you may not be able to do this yourself, but will have to ask the clinic administrator and consultant in charge to write to patients on your behalf. You will have to facilitate this by providing a suitable letter, appropriate inclusions such as a reply slip and prepaid envelope, and paying for the postage if necessary. You will need ethics approval to write to patients so make sure you include this strategy in your ethics submission.
13.1.2 Recruiting in-patients
If your research involves hospital in-patients the first step is to decide which wards are most likely to be caring for the patients you are interested in. This could be obvious: if you are interested in an obstetric issue you will focus on these wards; similarly critical care patients will be on intensive care. However, recruitment could be more general, so for example, if you are examining referrals to rehabilitation wards, patients may come from any number of wards. Similarly, patients throughout the hospital could have the problem you are interested in, such as poor mobility, cognitive impairment, pain, malnutrition and so on. If your patient group is diverse and could come from many wards try to focus on a limited number, if you try to cover all wards it will be time consuming and unproductive. Ask the ward staff if they think their ward will provide suitable patients; they will know best what type of patients they care for. Then it is a matter of going round the wards and locating possible patients and approaching them.
Before you start, don’t forget to inform the consultants and their teams that you will be recruiting patients under their care. Explain the study briefly, what is involved for their patients, and state that you have all the necessary approvals. They are responsible for each patient’s care while they are in hospital so it is essential that they know what you are doing. Occasionally, some consultants will object to the inclusion of their patients and you will have to respect this; however, in my experience this is rare.
The study I ran looking at patients who were taking an antibiotic is a good example of how a recruiting strategy can develop. Clearly, patients taking antibiotics were spread throughout the hospital and in theory I could recruit from any ward. I started by thinking through the exclusion criteria and working out if certain wards would not be fruitful. Because immune compromised patients were excluded I avoided the intensive care wards. I also had to recruit patients within two days of starting an antibiotic so long stay wards were also of little use. I needed to exclude patients who had recent previous antibiotic treatment and after a short time I found vascular surgery patients often had a history of frequent antibiotic use so I avoided this ward too. After several months I had refined my recruiting strategy to a limited number of wards, including admission wards, care of the elderly and respiratory wards. I could then really focus on building relationships with the staff on these wards to make recruitment as efficient and rapid as possible. The key was to check all new admissions as soon as possible to find out if they were going on antibiotics. I tried numerous approaches including obtaining the previous day’s admissions lists, liaising with emergency department doctors, asking medical teams on each ward to contact me if they prescribed antibiotics, and working with the ward pharmacists to highlight new patients. Many of these strategies failed, principally because people who work in hospitals are very busy and although they might want to help with research, it usually comes a long way down their priority list. The best way I found was to go to the wards and check personally with the staff there, and in the end this was the most time efficient and effective strategy.
In another study I worked on I was interested in recruiting patients just before they were discharged from hospital. Anyone who has worked in an acute hospital environment will know that predicting discharge dates is extremely difficult. Again the best way was to focus on particular wards, build up relationships with the ward staff and visit as often as possible. Finding time for a friendly chat or to help someone out paid huge dividends when it came to getting timely notification of someone going home.
13.2 Volunteers from the general public
Much health care research will involve people using the health care system, and hence volunteers can be recruited using the methods described in the previous section. Nevertheless, some research requires healthy volunteers or volunteers who are at risk of a particular condition but are currently not accessing the health care system. For this type of volunteer you will have to go out and recruit more widely from the community. There are several possible approaches that can be used individually or in combination, including advertising, writing letters, or publicising the research you are doing.
13.2.1 Advertising
Advertising in newspapers or with posters sited in work or public spaces can be an effective means of recruiting volunteers. You will need to investigate what is the best way locally and this may be a process of trial and error. If you know other researchers in the area, ask for advice.
Local papers may carry adverts; these will usually be at a cost, although some papers will provide free space for projects seeking volunteers (for example, the London Evening Standard). Ring your local papers and ask what they can offer you.
If you are using posters think about placing them in large offices, GP surgeries, sports centres, colleges, universities, or libraries. Before placing any adverts make sure you get the correct permissions to advertise and remember your advert or poster must have been approved by the ethics committee.
The group you are targeting will dictate the best places to advertise. For example, in the past I have looked for people who wanted to lose weight and a newspaper advert produced a large response. However, other studies requiring men with high cholesterol were harder to recruit for and we had to focus adverts on organisations with a high proportion of male employees, such as the police or fire service.
The following questions are worth asking when recruiting with adverts: