3. Day surgery
Melanie Oakley
CHAPTER CONTENTS
Advantages of day surgery36
Disadvantages of day surgery36
Day surgery nursing37
Anaesthesia in day surgery38
Recovery in day surgery39
Discharge of the patient from the day surgery unit41
Conclusion42
At the end of the chapter the reader should be able to:
• give a definition of day surgery and an explanation of what it involves
• discuss the history and development of day surgery
• state the advantages and possible disadvantages of day surgery
• discuss the surgical and anaesthetic techniques employed in day surgery
• describe the recovery of the patient following surgery
• discuss the discharge criteria for the day surgery patient.
Introduction
What is day surgery?
A surgical day case is a patient who is admitted for investigations or an operation on a planned non-resident basis, but who nonetheless requires facilities for recovery in a ward or unit set aside for this purpose (Royal College of Surgeons, 1992).
In 1992 the Royal College of Surgeons indicated that day surgery was the best option for 50% of all patients undergoing elective surgical procedures. Patients could receive a faster, more efficient service as day surgery patients, and hospital costs would decrease (Audit Commission, 1990). The National Health Service Management Executive (NHSME) Day Surgery Taskforce (1993) estimated that 60% of all elective surgery should be performed as day cases by 1997–98. By 2002, the NHS Plan predicted that this figure should increase to 75% (Department of Health, 2002). The NHS Institute recently reissued the 10 High Impact Changes for Service Improvement and Delivery, and one of the high impact changes is that day surgery should be the first choice for the majority of elective surgery cases (Department of Health, 2004, pp. 15–21).
Day surgery is a specialist area of care where patients are admitted into a designated day surgery unit for minor and intermediate surgery, and discharged home the same day. Specialist training and education are recognized as important elements for the provision of high-quality patient care in this area, and guidelines have been produced to ensure that patients receive high-quality care (NHS Modernisation Agency, 2002).
History and development of day surgery
The history of performing operations as day cases goes back nearly a century when it was reported in the British Medical Journal that Professor James Nicholl, a paediatric surgeon, and his colleagues had been performing day case operations at a children’s clinic in Glasgow (Nicholl, 1909, cited by Bradshaw and Davenport, 1989).
During the past decade there has been a steady increase in day case treatments and operations. The results of research demonstrate the quality and acceptability of such care alongside cost advantages (Audit Commission, 1991 and National Health Service Modernisation Agency, 2002). Day surgery has become popular, and its practice has accelerated throughout Europe.
Advantages of day surgery
The economic benefits of day surgery can be seen as reductions in waiting lists and the increased availability of inpatient hospital beds. However, reduced costs should not be seen as the only advantage of day surgery. High-quality patient care and patient acceptability need to be achieved alongside cost savings, in order to maintain an economical, efficient and quality service. Day surgery allows for a high throughput of patients and reduces surgical waiting lists. It also has a low incidence of major morbidity, reduced cross-infection risks, and lends itself to audit (NHS Modernisation Agency, 2002).
Many patients prefer to have their aftercare at home rather than in hospital, and patient surveys indicate high levels of satisfaction with day case treatment (Theus et al, 1995). Patients can avoid an unnecessary hospital stay, have minimal disruption of daily routine, and can return home to recover in familiar surroundings. Day surgery is not a new concept of care; it has been used throughout the last century. However, now that the benefits of day case procedures are evident, it has become increasingly popular.
Most surgical specialties can utilize a day surgery unit. In 1990 the Audit Commission produced a ‘basket of procedures’, which numbered 20; however, this ‘basket’ was updated in 2001 (Audit Commission, 2001) (Box 3.1). The British Association of Day Surgery put forward a further list of more major procedures that can also be performed as day surgery in 50% of cases, which is based upon the complexity, length and anaesthesia involved in the surgery (Cahill, 1999) (Box 3.2). This was extended with the Directory of Procedures (British Association of Day Surgery, 2006), where each procedure is listed against four possible treatment options (Table 3.1). However, it should be noted that some procedures require longer recovery times and so would only be possible as a true day case if performed in a morning session. Some procedures also require specialist equipment and training for clinicians to reach their full potential.
Box 3.1
• Orchidopexy • Circumcision • Inguinal hernia repair • Excision of breast lump • Anal fissure dilatation and excision • Haemorrhoidectomy • Laparoscopic cholecystectomy • Varicose vein stripping and ligation • Transurethral resection of bladder tumour • Excision of Dupuytren’s contracture • Carpal tunnel decompression | • Excision of ganglion • Arthroscopy • Bunion operations • Removal of metal ware • Extraction of cataract with/without implant • Correction of squint • Myringotomy • Tonsillectomy • Submucous resection • Reduction of nasal fracture • Operation for bat ears • Dilatation and curettage/hysteroscopy • Laparoscopy • Termination of pregnancy |
Box 3.2
• Laparoscopic hernia repair • Thoracoscopic sympathectomy • Submandibular gland excision • Partial thyroidectomy • Superficial parotidectomy • Wide excision of breast lump with axillary clearance • Urethrotomy • Bladder neck incision • Laser prostatectomy | • Transcervical resection of endometrium (TCRE) • Eyelid surgery • Arthroscopic meniscectomy • Arthroscopic shoulder decompression • Subcutaneous mastectomy • Rhinoplasty • Dentoalveolar surgery • Tympanoplasty |
Treatment option | Definition of length of stay in Directory |
---|---|
Procedure room | Operation that may be performed in a suitable clean environment outside of theatres, e.g. GP surgery |
Day surgery | Traditional day surgery |
23-hour stay | Patient is admitted and discharged within 24 hours |
Under 72-hour stay | Patient is admitted and discharged within 72 hours |
Disadvantages of day surgery
Some medical staff and managers are still unenthusiastic about the concepts of day surgery care, but training and education programmes have now been developed to increase interest and change attitudes. High standards of preoperative patient assessment and suitable anaesthetic techniques are necessary to run a successful day surgery unit, and both nurses and doctors require training in these areas, prior to accepting responsibility for day care management.
A few patients may refuse to have their operation on a day basis for fear of something unexpected happening at home after discharge, or being an extra burden on relatives. However, with good preoperative assessment, discharge planning in advance and a high input of patient education, these anxieties may be reduced, thereby enabling the patient to find day surgery care more acceptable. Patients are required to be physically fit for day surgery, have a responsible adult to care for them for at least 24 hours, and a suitable home environment in which to recover. Day surgery units require good equipment and facilities; and education, audit and research into day surgery should be supported to run a successful day surgery unit.
Day surgery nursing
Day surgery nursing differs from ward or theatre nursing because of the potential for nurses to work in all areas of the day surgery unit. Most planned day surgery units have areas identified for preoperative assessment, anaesthetics, operating theatre, recovery and ward facilities. All nurses working in day surgery should ideally be trained to be multi-skilled and able to work in each area, perhaps on a rotation system. Staff can expand their practice by becoming competent anaesthetic, operating theatre and recovery nurses, as well as being skilful in patient assessment before and after surgery (Hodge, 1999).
The benefits of staff rotation are greater job satisfaction, more effective and efficient staffing and good staff morale. Patients also benefit from a more knowledgeable nursing staff, and it highlights the specialized role of the day surgery nurse. The rotation system prevents work becoming too routine, and allows staff to become competent in nursing patients from a variety of specialities (Hodge, 1999).
In order to facilitate nurse rotation throughout a day surgery unit, nurses should be intensively trained so that they achieve a variety of skills. They will need theatre nursing skills, knowledge of anaesthetic techniques and the ability to deliver immediate postoperative care to patients. This is in addition to demonstrating good communication skills and a caring attitude towards patients and their relatives (Hodge, 1999).
Day surgery nursing – patient care
Although day surgery is seen as a major vehicle in reducing long waiting lists, it must not be regarded as a panacea for waiting list problems. The shift away from conventional hospital stays towards shorter periods in hospital will herald a change not only in hospital size and layout but also in nursing practice. It is essential, therefore, that nurses take on board these changes and realize the contribution they must make to ensure that they deliver a high standard of patient care within a high-quality service. The commitment of nurses in the day surgery setting to achieve this is paramount, in order to instil in their patients the confidence to accept this shift towards shorter hospital stays and to be adequately prepared for their hospital stay and discharge home.
The time spent by patients in the day surgery unit is short, with the pre- and postoperative periods being condensed into hours rather than days. It could be argued that the patient requires less time to recover from their treatment because of this; however, it must be recognized that, on the whole, although the hospital stay may be shorter, the period of convalescence may not alter greatly from that of an inpatient for the same procedure. The place at which the convalescence period is spent is changed, however, in that it takes place outside of the hospital environment. Whether this period takes 1 day or longer, the impact on the patient may be great. Hospitalization and subsequent recovery at home will impinge on the patient’s social circumstances. It will have implications for work commitments, and the necessary help and arrangements will be needed to achieve a satisfactory and uneventful recovery. It should not be forgotten that fears and anxieties regarding treatment may be just as real in the day surgery patient (Mitchell, 1997).
Preoperative assessment in day surgery
The role of the preoperative assessment for surgical patients has been discussed in depth in Chapter 1. However, it is worth illustrating at this point how preoperative assessment in day surgery is integral to the whole process. Day surgery has led the way in preoperative assessment, because particularly at the inception of widespread day surgery there were very strict criteria laid down as to the patients who were suitable for day surgery and those who were not. Also, there were strict discharge criteria which initially were very inflexible. However, as day surgery has become the ‘norm’, rather than a new phenomenon, these guidelines have been adjusted to suit the needs of the patient and the service (NHS Modernisation Agency, 2002). It is sensible that when the preoperative assessment was rolled out to incorporate all patients undergoing surgery, preoperative assessment in day surgery was looked at as the model upon which to base it.