CHAPTER TWENTY-ONE Clinical leadership in action
Developing the health care management team
At the completion of this chapter, the reader will be able to:
INTRODUCTION1
Obviously, the most expeditious method of accomplishing anything in the nursing unit is to simply order someone to perform what is necessary to get it accomplished. But that procedure is seldom truly effective and is not representative of what leadership in health care requires today. Today, the nurse leader will have difficulty finding anyone who will tell her that leading her unit will be an easy process to accomplish, or that dictatorial direction is the most proficient method of management, because those things simply are not true. In fact, developing and leading a team of professionals in today’s health care organisation is far more difficult than simply giving orders to the staff. But the extra effort required to accomplish the process is worth the price because the effect that a well-organised and motivated team can have on the success of a nursing unit is readily apparent. In virtually every performance area known, team performance has proven itself to be far superior to individual accomplishment. The hard work and effort that the nurse manager puts into developing and managing her team will pay off in increased production, higher quality patient care, lower turnover and absenteeism, lower risk, and improved staff loyalty (Blanchard 1999).
There is no quick or simple way to develop nursing leaders or the teams of performers that will follow them. It is a process of learning, trusting, supporting, and, above all, caring. It requires managers and individual members of the staff to continually extend themselves towards improvement and never allow themselves or any member of their team to be above gaining new insights or studying innovative procedures and methods (Loeb & Kindel 1999).
CREATING A WINNING TEAM
The sensations experienced through winning and success are extraordinary. These sensations alone should provide a natural incentive for leaders to create the best possible teams, but that is not always the way things occur. In fact, it takes a tremendous amount of effort, perseverance and insight to create a winning team. The leader must employ an understanding of human nature, as well as demonstrate an ability to carefully align skills and personalities. It is the effort put into the creation of the team by the leader that ultimately signals the team’s ability to succeed.
While most people in leadership roles will be quick to acknowledge the importance of the team, few really understand what needs to be done to create, nurture and guide such a unit (Belasco & Stayer 1994). As the complexity of health care continues to grow, the practice of effective team creation will become more and more critical to future success; therefore, it is important that every nurse manager understands what team building is about. If the individual nurse manager implements and follows the procedures outlined below, she should be able to develop effective teams that will satisfy the growing demands of her unit (Melohn 1994).
Step 1—Hire the right people
As the leader of the nursing unit, the nurse manager must keep herself, and the members of her team, extremely concerned with exactly whom they allow to become new members of the team. The reason for being extremely careful is easy to understand; the people that they allow to join will eventually become the exact individuals who help shape the unit’s and, ultimately, every individual team member’s continued success. The people that the nurse manager hires become part of the only real tool she has to perform the mission she has been given. With this thought in mind, it becomes very easy to see just how critical it is for the manager to put the right person, at the right time, in the right position. Failure to accomplish this fundamental process correctly is more than simply wrong; in fact, such an error can have wideranging ramifications. One of the truisms of management is that it is better to keep the position open than hire the wrong person. The nurse manager should resist the natural impulse to allow the availability of qualified personnel, or lack thereof, to influence her determination to find a quality employee.
Step 2—Make your team diverse
While it is generally preferred to lead a team comprised of seasoned veterans, it is most often far more productive to have a good mix of experience and youth. The rookies will force you to sacrifice a little in the professional categories, but they will bring you a fresh perspective and significantly different attitudes. Part of the problem with hiring elite professionals is that they have been there and done that—some of them many times before—and others will think that they have. While experience provides benefits, a growing organisation needs to have enthusiasm, energy and a willingness to try new approaches and concepts. If you load your team down with too much experience, you may be creating a situation where the flexibility you need most will be sacrificed to those who are unwilling to deviate from traditional roles and approaches (Mackay & Blanchard 1999).
We have said that diversity is what you want to strive for in establishing your team. Now, let’s throw in a word of caution: Do not try to make your team too diverse. Diversity can also work against you. For example, if you look into the talent pool and select nothing but newcomers with new, untested ideas, you will run the risk of having to spend your time acting like a firefighter, running from place to place putting out fires. A classic example of bringing in too many young, talented and creative people and not enough seasoned veterans can be seen by reviewing the performance of the Clinton White House in its first 90 days. President Clinton brought a tremendous pool of talented, excited and energetic individuals with him to staff the White House; the problem was that very few, including the President and First Lady, had previous experience in government at that level and together they made some colossal errors. Seemingly insignificant decisions, such as how the White House travel office would be run, ended in a powerful backlash and embarrassing situations for the new president and his government. The lesson learned from the early Clinton days was that intelligence, desire and imagination are not all that is needed to run an organisation. These things need to be tempered with experience and commonsense. Too many inexperienced people will force the leader to spend a disproportionate amount of time solving their problems, instead of working on the team’s goals.
Step 3—Limit team size
While the nursing unit is a far cry from a baseball field, good ones are developed around a team concept that involves very similar concepts, and, if developed correctly, a small, well-honed team can and will always outperform a large, unprepared one (Bridges 1998). It is not the size that matters in softball, or in nursing—it is the quality. As the developer of the nursing unit’s team, the nurse manager should always be looking to ‘right-size’ her team. In fact, it is a primary responsibility of management to continually look for means to reduce costs and overhead expenses, and if you are not taking hard looks at the size of your unit and developing methods of getting the work done more efficiently and with fewer personnel, you are not doing the complete job. If, however, you are doing these things, your efforts should be governed by the following two basic concepts of team management: