Chapter 8. Accessing the Nursing Research Literature
Paul Murphy and Seamus Cowman
▪ Introduction
▪ Choosing a database
▪ Other sources of information
▪ Search process
▪ Subject headings, Boolean and related features
▪ Evaluation of search strategy
▪ Identifying evidence-based studies
▪ Searching the open web
▪ Conclusion
Introduction
With a continuing increase in the volume of nursing information being published, there is a growing need to make that information accessible. One current directory of periodicals lists over 700 nursing journals and many more health care journals are potentially relevant (Ulrichs 2006). As we cannot read everything, we need to develop the information skills to identify and locate relevant documents when needed. There are some core information skills which can be applied across a range of publication formats and media.
Choosing the best sources is a skill acquired through familiarity with a range of nursing publications. For example, a pharmacopoeia might give sufficient information on a medication query; a review article summarising recent evidence-based research may be the solution to a clinical problem; guidelines for practice might be available on a reputable website. In other clinical and research contexts, there may be more complex problems to be solved and a more systematic search for information is needed. A literature review is conducted to create a picture of what is currently known about a problem situation and to identify what knowledge gaps may exist. Identifying pertinent studies, reviewing them and then clarifying the areas of further investigation all contribute to the development of research (Younger 2004).
Nursing information may be categorised according to the degree to which it is based upon empirical evidence from research or practice. Primary, research information derives mainly from original data collected and analysed in methodologically rigorous studies. Secondary information derives from authors presenting and discussing the work of others. Theoretical works contribute to other levels of knowledge building. Descriptive accounts and case reports may be valuable in presenting information on areas where there has been little or no formal research.
The impact of evidence-based medicine on nursing literature was noted by Morrisey and DeBourgh (2001), as was the subsequent drive to develop access to the literature among nurses. The growth of evidence-based practice has led to a clearer focus upon identifying specific types of scientifically sound studies in the literature. The study types concerned range from systematic reviews and randomised controlled trials to cohort and case studies. The Centre for Evidence Based Medicine at Oxford has a useful guide to the various levels of evidence in published research (Centre for Reviews and Dissemination 2005a) (Table 8.1).
Study or document type | Publication format (printed or electronic) | Access tool |
---|---|---|
Systematic reviews Meta-analysis Randomised controlled trials Clinical trials Cohort studies Case-based studies Reviews | Journal article Cochrane Review | Journal index databases and evidence-based databases: CINAHL MEDLINE Cochrane Library Other bibliographic databases |
Opinion, editorial, letters | Journal | Journal index databases |
Textbooks, monographs | Book | Local and national library catalogues Online book services Web search engines CINAHL |
Conference proceedings | Published proceedings | CINAHL Health care web portals Web search engines |
Reports | Report | Library catalogues Health care web portals Web search engines Official agencies |
Clinical guidelines | Guideline | CINAHL Health care web portals Web search engines Health care agencies |
Theses | Thesis | Dissertation abstracts Index to theses CINAHL |
Reference data, drug information | Reference book | Manual Pharmacopoeia Formulary website |
News and general information | Journal Magazine Website | Keyword search engines Health care web portals Practitioner journals |
Journals are now commonly published on the web, but searchers cannot rely on general web search engines to discover articles. Web search engines work well for general information but specialist bibliographic databases such as CINAHL (Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health) and MEDLINE have been developed specifically to index journal articles. Human indexers evaluate the articles and add abstracts and subject information to aid the searcher in assessing the work described. Bibliographic databases are professional finding tools; however, they do not always include the complete full text of all articles indexed. Accessing the full text of articles is often another stage in the search process. Much will depend for instance upon whether an institution or a library has a subscription to a journal.
Choosing a database
There are a significant number of nursing databases, each with a different coverage of nursing sources (Table 8.2). The journals included for indexing are selected by the database publishers; not all journals relevant to a particular sub-specialty or geographic area may be included in any one database. Morrisey and DeBourgh (2001) discuss the spread of nursing literature across medical, nursing and social science sources and they suggest that nurses must refine their literature search skills to improve effectiveness. Hek et al (2000) identified over 20 databases being used in some systematic reviews.
Database | Type | Features |
---|---|---|
CINAHL – Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health | CINAHL has indexed over 3000 nursing and allied health journals online from 1982. CINAHL covers nursing, biomedicine, complementary medicine, consumer health and many allied health disciplines. Selectively indexes health care books, dissertations, conference proceedings, standards of practice, educational software and book chapters | www.cinahl.com Commercial, subscription database available on a number of search systems and interfaces Indexes over 1000 journals Full text option with over 300 journals |
MEDLINE | The US National Library of Medicine’sbibliographic database covering the fields of medicine, nursing, the health care system, and the pre-clinical sciences worldwide. MEDLINE contains bibliographic citations and author abstracts from more than 4800 biomedical journals | Available on a number of searchservices Free version (PubMed www.pubmed.gov) 12 million + citations from mid1960s with some older material |
The Cochrane Library | The Cochrane Library consists of a regularly updated collection of evidence-based medicine databases including the unique Cochrane Reviews (over 4000) produced by the global Cochrane Collaboration. Cochrane Reviews are systematic reviews of the most reliable information on the effects of interventions in health care. The Library as a whole is a mix of fulltext reviews, references to articles and reports and registries of trials with over 500 000 items in all | www.cochrane.org Cochrane Database of SystematicReviews Database of Abstracts of Reviews ofEffects (DARE) Central Register of Controlled Trials Database of Methodology Reviews Methodology Register Health Technology Assessmentdatabase NHS Economic Evaluation Database |
Web of Science | Includes the Social Sciences Citation Index,a multidisciplinary index to over 1725 journals across 50 social sciences disciplines and indexed overall from 1956 forward; included are Nursing, Public Health, Social Issues, Law, Sociology, Psychology and Psychiatry | scientific.thomson.com Citation indexes enable tracking allof whom reference an author or work |
PsycINFO | PsycINFO covers behavioural sciences andmental health. Indexes journals in psychology and related fields such as psychiatry, management, business, education, social science, law, medicine, and social work | www.apa.org/psycinfo/ over 2 350 000 records Nearly 2000 journals Selected book indexing Dissertations Historic records |
British Nursing Index | BNI is a nursing and midwifery database,covering over 200 UK journals and other English language titles. A collaborative production involving UK nursing libraries, it is available from a number of vendors | www.bniplus.co.uk |
MIDIRS (Midwives Information and Resource Service) | MIDIRS contains over 100 000 references to articles, book chapters, reports relating to midwifery, pregnancy, childbirth and infant care | www.midirs.org Specialist database now availablethrough OVID |
AMED – Allied and Complementary Medicine Database | AMED is produced by the Health Care Information Service of the British Library. It covers selected journals in professions allied to medicine (physiotherapy, occupational therapy, speech therapy), in complementary medicine and in palliative care | www.bl.uk/collections/health/amed.html Specialist database |
ASSIA: Applied Social Sciences Index and Abstracts | ASSIA indexes health, social services,psychology, sociology, economics, politics, and education journals. Covers anxiety disorders, ethnic studies, family, geriatrics, nursing, immigration, child abuse, psychology and social issues | www.csa.com US-based publisher Coverage from 1987 500 journals from 16 countries |
There is potential for some overlap between databases, but there may also be gaps; some databases will not index reports, books or theses. Newly published journals may publish on emerging issues but it may be some time before databases start indexing them. There are also access and subscription issues; many of the most important databases are offered by different vendors with various search interfaces and features. CINAHL for instance is available from publishers such as OVID, DIALOG and EBSCO.
Other sources of information
The UK’s national gateway for nursing information, NMAP – Nursing, Midwifery and the Allied Health Professions (http://nmap.ac.uk), is a good source of information on health care resources.
Nursing dissertations are included in ProQuest’s Dissertations & Theses Database (http://www. proquest.com) and the Index to Theses (http://www.theses.com).
Search process
Searching is often an intuitive, iterative process with the results retrieved at each stage informing the steps used to proceed further. Searches on most systems can range from basic searches using a few keywords to more complex searches which use the many advanced search features. In the simplified record from CINAHL on the OVID system presented in Table 8.3 the words and phrases in the title, abstract and subject headings fields are the basis for successful search matches. If the system matches the search words with terms in article records, then these articles will be deemed to be relevant and will be presented in the results.
Title | Post-operative pain management in day surgery |
Author | Skilton, M. |
Source | Nursing Standard 2003 Jun4–10; 17(38): 39–44. (17 ref) |
Abstract | The author carried out aliterature review of post-operative pain management in day surgery units… |
Journal subset | Double Blind Peer Reviewed.Expert Peer Reviewed. Nursing Journals. Peer Reviewed Journals |
CINAHL subject headings | Ambulatory Care Nursing Ambulatory Surgery/ae [AdverseEffects] Narcotics/tu [Therapeutic use] Pain/pa [Pathology] Postoperative Pain/dt [DrugTherapy] Postoperative Pain/ep[Epidemiology] Postoperative Pain/nu [Nursing] Postoperative Pain/pf[Psychosocial Factors] *Postoperative Pain Reflection |
Publication type | Journal Article, Review, Tables/Charts |
Search strategy
In addition to thinking of all possible variants, there is some control possible by truncating words; ‘therap*’ (with an asterisk), for example, will find the terms ‘therapy’, ‘therapist’ and ‘therapeutic’ in most databases.
Relationships between different variables may also have to be considered. Suppose you are interested in investigating the relationship between stress, health beliefs and chronic fatigue syndrome. A search on the general aspects of stress and beliefs is one component. You may need to discover more about chronic fatigue syndrome and related conditions separately. You then need to bring all elements together to discover if any research links both. In CINAHL terms, the search elements might be grouped like this:
▪ stress OR stress, psychological;
▪ health beliefs OR attitude to health;
▪ chronic fatigue syndrome OR myalgic encephalomyelitis OR post viral fatigue syndrome.