CHAPTER 13. Using Simulated Learning
Chapter Aims
The purpose of this chapter is to gain insight into how simulation can be used in pre-registration nurse education. After reading this chapter you will be able to:
• Identify the key elements of simulated learning environments/simulation.
• Evaluate strengths and weaknesses of your own teaching style in relation to facilitating simulation.
• Plan effectively for a simulation session.
• Plan effectively for debriefing following simulation.
What is simulated learning?
Currently in all aspects of healthcare there is renewed focus on patient safety and quality indicators. Simulation-based training can help practitioners at all levels to reduce risk and improve the safety and quality of patient care. It is, however, most widely used in pre-registration programmes. You may feel this is only relevant to lecturers in the university but as this chapter will show simulation can be used and indeed is frequently used by mentors in practice. There is also increasing involvement of mentors in university simulation centres with the NMC seeing this as best practice.
First, don’t be daunted. Simulation is simply another tool in your repertoire of teaching and learning skills and although it may include technologically advanced tools, it doesn’t have to. The simulation process ‘allows interactive, and at times immersive, activity by recreating all or part of a clinical experience without exposing patients to the associated risks’ (Maran and Glavin, 2003 p. 22).
Students are required to respond to situations as they would in the clinical environment usually in real time, applying and integrating knowledge skills and critical thinking. Debriefing and feedback on performance is crucial to the process to ensure that learning is accompanied by assessment (usually informal) and reinforcement of good practice. Participants are active rather than passive receivers of information. This ‘learning by doing’ approach to learning is one that suits many nursing students.
Why use simulation
Simulation is used in many disciplines, particularly when the reality may be dangerous, events are rare or errors are costly in human and/or financial terms. Obvious examples are the aviation industry, where sophisticated flight simulators are mandatory in the training of pilots to maintain their skills, the military and the nuclear power industry. Although the use of simulation and simulators has a relatively long history in medical and nursing education, it is only relatively recently that it has been recognized by the NMC as an essential component of nursing and midwifery programmes.
Using simulation in nurse education
Students on nursing programmes need to learn practical clinical skills in order to become competent. Some of these psychomotor skills are technically advanced; in the wider context of patient care many involve high levels of cognition, critical thinking and communication skills. It would appear that the acquisition and development of competence in these skills is becoming more challenging as the complexity of healthcare increases and the context changes. As modes of healthcare delivery change there may be less and less opportunities for students to experience certain aspects of care or practise specific skills during their placements. Students gain experience in a variety of settings other than acute care. Whilst this is entirely appropriate, it means that students’ exposure to the hospital environment, where many clinical skills were traditionally honed, is reduced. Even in the hospital setting changing practices, for example, the increase in day case surgery, mean that students may not have the opportunity to practise certain skills, such as suture removal and injection techniques, as they once did. Mentors have many competing demands upon their time, whilst the NMC code of conduct requires all qualified nurses to support students, the needs of patients will by necessity take priority.
Against this background of an increasing patient safety and risk management agenda and reduced availability of clinical placements, the interest in and demand for simulation-based training has increased. Simulation is being recognized as a way of offering the opportunity to train multiprofessional groups of staff for real patient situations in a realistic context in a way that is risk free for patients and, if correctly facilitated, risk free for staff. Through simulation-based teaching, students are provided with the opportunity to rehearse skills, procedures and events not often used. They are also provided an opportunity to refine and develop skills used on a more frequent basis but which can not be rehearsed and practiced in the real environment for practical and/or ethical reasons.
Simulation in clinical practice
In recent years many healthcare organizations have invested in sophisticated manikins and other equipment in order to provide simulation-based training to staff, which you may have used. The NMC has agreed that pre-registration nursing students can spend up to 300 hours of their 2300 hours of practice time in simulated environment but recommends that mentors should be involved.
Provision of simulated learning
There are many ways to provide simulation-based training. Sometimes simulation will involve highly sophisticated manikins, at other times it may involve actors or a mixture of both. Simulated learning can also take place in a virtual environment in the form of interactive computer-based learning packages. The key to all of these approaches is immersion. The scenario or patient situation created must be as realistic as possible in order that the participant becomes immersed in it and reacts and responds as if it were real. Simulation most often takes place in a university-based setting where students and practitioners come together to provide this experience with the support of the students’ lecturers. Whilst these facilities are often well equipped and provide access to staff who are experienced in simulation, it requires a high level of planning and co-ordination to get everyone in the same place at the same time.
Increasingly, simulation is taking place in the clinical environment, making use of a vacant space such as a side room or empty ward area or the organization’s own skills centre. The former have the advantage of creating a more realistic environment and an approach used by many mentors. In either setting the key to a successful learning experience is an enthusiastic, able and clinically credible facilitator.
Types of simulation
The type of simulation chosen for any particular learning experience will be dictated by the learning outcomes and facilities available and so must be carefully thought through beforehand. The following sections provide some examples of simulated scenarios you may like to be involved in or could use in your workplace or in a skills/simulation centre.
Use of role play/actors
A simulated clinical scenario can be created with people acting as the patient/client, and/or in some cases a relative. The ‘actors’ may be professional actors or a standardized patient (SP). SPs are usually volunteers who have been prepared for various roles. More usually the ‘actors’ will be colleagues; ideally they should not be someone with whom the student is very familiar. It is very difficult for the student to relate to someone as a patient when they are in fact known to them, such as the ward sister or a university lecturer and this detracts from the realism of the learning experience. Preparation of the actor whether they be professionals, SPs or colleagues is essential. They need to be clear about the student’s learning outcomes and avoid any tendency to overact or ad lib. When using actors one of the key learning objectives is usually related to communication skills and the ‘patient’ can be primed to exhibit certain behaviours or ask particular questions but should react as realistically as possible to what the student actually does or says.
If you use actors during a simulation exercise then prepare them beforehand on how to stay in character. You may like to consider giving them a detailed synopsis of who they are, perhaps even based on a ‘real’ patient they can identify with. This will be easier if they are not known to the student.
Mixed task trainer/actor
Using this approach an actor can be used in conjunction with a training manikin or task trainer such as a catheterization model or venepuncture/cannulation arm. This allows the student to practise a potentially hazardous technique safely but in the context of a patient situation (see Case study 13.1)
Case study 13.1
A student reflects on her experience of simulated learning
‘Last semester I was required to simulate the care I would give to a patient who was a diabetic and required an injection of insulin. When I went into the room it all seemed so real I actually forgot it was a simulation. There was an actor dressed in a hospital gown sitting in a chair. In my scenario they were a newly diagnosed diabetic and I needed to give a subcutaneous injection of insulin. There was even an injectable pad taped to the actor so I could really demonstrate my injection technique. My lecturer was standing off to the side watching and listening to everything I did. I had to demonstrate that I could give the medication correctly, communicate with the patient, answer questions and explain exactly what I was doing. At the end of the simulation I got feedback about how I did from my lecturer and we went through it step by step so I could see how to improve next time. I found it a brilliant learning experience.’
For example a student could be required to simulate catheterization technique by communicating with an actor but performing the actual task on a catheterization model. The learning activity would require the student to demonstrate the following:
• correct checking and preparation of all equipment
• gaining the patient’s consent and providing adequate explanation
• answer the patient questions knowledgeably and in a way that will help to allay anxiety
• recognize if at any point further assistance is needed
• demonstrate safe and effective catheterization technique.
Use of patient simulators
There are many patient simulators on the market, some highly sophisticated and capable of producing highly realistic physiological responses that might be exhibited by a patient in a variety of states of health and illness. These are best suited to creating a scenario where the main objective is for the students to assess, observe, interpret and act on physiological changes that cannot be recreated in an actor. The addition of a ‘patient voice’ to the manikin enables the students to verbally interact with the patient. For example, a patient simulator can be set up as a postoperative patient (intravenous fluids running, catheter, wounds, drains and dressing in situ, oxygen in place). The patient simulator can be used to recreate signs of shock due to blood loss.
This kind of simulation can be resource intensive; someone is needed to operate the simulator and voice. This could be, but is not necessarily, the same person. In many cases it is helpful to have someone other than the person facilitating the simulation to be the person who is called upon to help. The more realistic you can make the simulation exercise the better the learning experience for the student. If you are undertaking a simulation exercise in practice consider having the actual person involved (e.g. the ward sister who would be called in a real-life situation) as this makes it all the more real. In addition to this you may chose to have other actors taking on other roles, for example as other patients or relatives who are either present or on the telephone.
The student must demonstrate:
• full systematic ABCDE assessment of the patient
• interpret and act upon the findings of the assessment appropriately
• document findings and seek appropriate help
• communicate with the patient and/or relative throughout in a manner that is knowledgeable and reassuring
• provide a clear, concise and relevant handover to the relevant member of staff.
All these examples of simulated experiences allow students to practise their skills and apply knowledge to patient care in a realistic and contextualized way. This approach can prepare them for similar situations in the real world of practice. This also allows assessment of and feedback on skills and knowledge in a way that is risk-free to patients and the student.
Are you and your area prepared for simulated learning?
Before you start to use simulation within your mentoring role, whether in the clinical area or in an educational establishment you must ensure that you have prepared both yourself and the learning environment.
Opportunities for simulation
You should start by asking yourself why you would like to use simulation as an approach to learning. Some key questions include:
• What aspects of practice learning will we be using simulation for?
• Why is simulation useful here?
• What is the outcome or level of practice activity that we want the student to perform?
No doubt you will be able to identify a number quite quickly. For example, simulation is easily adaptable and a great learning experience for the following types of situations:
• patient assessment
• injection technique and other key skills
• communication skills
• basic life support.
Activity 13.1 asks you to explore this further.
Activity 13.1
Opportunities for simulated learning
Take some time to think about an aspect of practice where simulation could be used in your clinical area. Try to think how you would plan this session. You might like to separate this plan into categories:
• How many students will you have?
• Where is the simulation taking place? In trust/clinical area or in an educational establishment?
• What are your learning outcomes?
• What behaviours/actions are you expecting from students as part of the session?
• If some students are observing – what else will they be doing at that time?
• What resources do you have and which other staff are available to help?
Planning effective simulation
The simulated learning environment needs to be as realistic as possible, so what is learnt and rehearsed is transferred easily into future practice. Within the clinical area it may be relatively easier to recreate a realistic environment as they will already be readily equipped with appropriate resources. Remember that empty wards and clinical areas are ideal venues for simulation as they can be quickly transformed into a realistic clinical environment.
Within a university simulation will require careful planning and sufficient resources to ‘mock up’ a convincing clinical setting. Planning will need to start early, so that equipment and supplies are available in good time.
On any manikin or human actor used within the simulation a range of recipes and procedures can be incorporated to mimic appropriate clinical situations or conditions such as bleeding, fake vomit, malaena, pus, etc. This practice is often referred to in literature and simulator user guides as ‘’moulage’. For access to tips and useful recipes for ‘moulage’ you can go to a number of websites, which include www.meti.com or www.laerdal.com.
Preparing teaching/clinical colleagues

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

