The Process of Helping
Christine L. Williams DNSc, APRN, BC
Carol M. Davis DPT, EdD, MS, FAPTA
OBJECTIVES
To describe the characteristics of a helping interview
To portray the qualities of an effective interviewer
To emphasize the importance of both thoughts and feelings in communication
To emphasize the importance of effective communication in the initial stages of the relationship
To examine the risks and rewards of communicating clearly in the presence of intense feelings
Therapeutic interaction requires new skills, but more than that, it requires unlearning old ways of communicating that will not work in a therapeutic relationship. This chapter is devoted to teaching a new way of communicating with the express purpose of developing a healing alliance with clients.
Remember that the client is not simply the person with an illness or injury, but his or her entire family is your client as well. Be aware of the need to include family members in your assessment and planning. Even when the “identified client” wants your help, the cooperation of supportive family members can make the difference between success and failure of the plan of care.
When clients are ill, they often feel afraid and vulnerable. They may be in the midst of a major life crisis such as birth or death. They may be caring for a family member who is dying. Most people resist giving over some control of their lives to strangers. They may not welcome this encounter with a nurse. The underlying theme in this chapter is to help you communicate in ways that foster opportunities for growth or solve problems while respecting and honoring clients during their health care experience.
As nurses, we recognize that the client may feel at a distinct disadvantage. At least from their perspective, we possess the knowledge and skills to manage the situation. Our interest, genuineness, acceptance, and positive regard are critical to establishing a healing relationship. The trust we foster will influence how much information we obtain during the assessment and how much the client benefits from our help.
▪ THE HEALTHCARE ENCOUNTER
Without effective communication, we are unable to acquire objective and subjective information to make health care decisions with our clients, and we are unable to utilize the relationship between nurse and client for therapeutic ends. This chapter focuses on sorting out emotion-laden communication to help clients identify and solve their own problems. Sometimes the first encounter with a client is in the home or outpatient clinic. If there is no emergency, the nurse can focus on collecting comprehensive information to better understand the client. In other situations, encounters are brief. (See Table 3-1.) The context of each interaction will affect the extent of the information collected and the nature of the nurse’s approach; however, many principles remain constant.
The interview is the first opportunity to convey a professional healing attitude, and it must be learned and practiced to develop skill. Learning therapeutic communication is like learning a new language. At first
it will feel awkward. You will wonder if your words sound artificial. Gradually, as you practice, it will sound more and more natural. When you see the results in the trust and confidence of your clients, you will be encouraged to keep working at it.
it will feel awkward. You will wonder if your words sound artificial. Gradually, as you practice, it will sound more and more natural. When you see the results in the trust and confidence of your clients, you will be encouraged to keep working at it.
Table 3-1 Brief vs Extended Nurse-Client Interactions | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Your words and inner attitude must be in harmony for the interview to be therapeutic. For the best results, the nurse must feel confident, peaceful, at one with his or her self, and genuinely willing to establish a healing relationship. Take a few deep breaths to relax before you begin. Focusing on the client’s needs rather than your own feelings of awkwardness will help you to forget your self-consciousness.
Meeting the Client
Your introduction will include the use of your full name and the client’s formal name. After the initial introduction, it is appropriate to ask the client what name he or she would like you to use. Many of us have had the experience of having our names mispronounced or shortened in ways that left us feeling vaguely and unnecessarily uncomfortable. Endearments such as “sweetie” or “mamma” are never appropriate. Your nonverbal behavior must convey respect and warmth. Position yourself at eye level rather than standing over the client as he or she lies in bed or sits in a wheelchair. Lean slightly toward the client to convey interest. Maintaining eye contact while staying at an appropriate social distance (4 feet away) is important in beginning a successful relationship.
Active Listening
Active listening is a form of therapeutic listening that helps the client clearly convey what he or she is trying to say. It involves paraphrasing the client’s words to clarify whether or not you have caught the client’s intended meaning. You must suspend your thoughts and attend exclusively to the nonverbal behavior and the words of the other person. This is not easy and requires practice. Your goal is to understand rather than judge or defend against. For some, it will require great effort to resist responding with a suggestion of what to do or with an argument. One word you will want to avoid at such times is “but.”
Active listening is made up of three different processes:1
Restatement—repeating the words of the client as you heard them.
Example: “You better call the doctor because I’m leaving this hospital today!”
Restatement: “You want to go home today?”
Restatement can be annoying if not timed appropriately. When done well, it assures the client that you have, indeed, heard what he or she is saying. The main purpose of restatement is to help the client continue speaking and should only be used in the initial phases of active listening. When you have reassured the client that you heard his or her words, reflection and clarification become more useful responses.
Reflection—verbalizing both the content and the implied feelings of the speaker.
Example: “No one seems to know what’s wrong with me. I’ve had so many tests and no one tells me anything. I’ve had it!”
Reflection: “You’re tired of all the tests and frustrated because you still don’t know what’s wrong?”
The purpose of reflection is to express in words the feelings and attitudes sensed behind the words of the speaker. This aspect of listening indicates you are hearing more than just the words—you are hearing the emotion behind them. Awareness of feelings is critical to identifying the real problem. Notice the client’s nonverbal behavior. Does it reinforce what the client is saying? Does it contradict the client’s words? Sometimes we guess incorrectly, but this gives the client the chance to clarify for us and for him- or herself exactly what he or she is feeling. When the nurse wants to help the client to examine both thoughts and feelings, clarification is used.
Clarification—summarizing or simplifying the client thoughts and feelings and resolving confused verbalizations into clear, concise statements.
Example: “When the doctor told me I needed some tests, I thought I would be out of here in a couple of days. But I’ve been sitting here all weekend doing nothing and now you’re telling me I still need more tests. I can’t stay here; I need to get back to work. I’m not sure what I’m supposed to do. I can’t afford to just lie around here another day.”
Clarification: “You thought you would be discharged by Friday? Now you realize that the tests are going to take longer than you expected and you are worried about missing work?”
These skills take practice, as does resisting the impulse to fix the problem. In this case, the client may begin to feel some relief just because he or she has been heard and may begin to problem solve on his or her own: “I will call my supervisor and explain that I haven’t had a chance to talk to the doctor yet. I don’t really want to leave if there is something really wrong.”
Nonverbal Communication
We communicate more with nonverbal behavior than we do with words. Our nonverbal behavior conveys how we feel regardless of what we say. The nurse’s nonverbal communication can either facilitate or hinder the quality of the interview. Key nonverbal elements of a helping interview include use of space (eliminate physical barriers such as a desk between you and the client), time (minimize interruptions), appropriate posture (avoiding rigid posture, slouching, or defiant gestures), voice inflection (appropriate speed and volume; warmth and genuine interest conveyed versus flatness or excessive use of “you knows”), and eliminating distracting body movements (twitching, shaking foot, tapping pencil).
Congruence
Congruence is a term that indicates that the verbal and nonverbal messages match.2 For example, congruence is present when the nurse admits that he or she is frustrated or irritated rather than denying those feelings. If the nurse denies feelings, nonverbal responses such as muscle tension and facial expression will communicate the feeling to the client anyway and create confusion. Incongruence appears dishonest or “not ringing true.” How often have we been caught in incongruence when someone asks for a compliment: “Well, do you like my new haircut or not?” “Well yes, it’s okay I guess.” What was felt was less than okay but no one likes to appear rude. When a person is congruent, he or she appears to be open, honest, genuine, and authentic. Nonverbal cues and tone of voice are consistent with the words spoken.
Congruence requires self-awareness. Before speaking, you must consider both feelings and thoughts and reconcile conflicts such as wanting to not be hurtful, yet wanting to be honest. A congruent response to the requested compliment might be: “You know, I noticed you had a new haircut, but I really liked it the old way.” With this response, the person realizes that you value honesty and are willing to be honest but can avoid being rude. The message “rings true” and you feel better. More important, the person knows you will resist trying to please others and disregarding your own feelings.
Congruence is best conveyed when it is communicated with sensitivity. It should never be used as a rationalization for insensitive and rude honesty.
Communicating Emotions
Many of us are rather unaware of our day-to-day communication style and are surprised when someone misunderstands the message we have tried to convey. It is difficult to come outside of ourselves and notice how we interact with others. Some of us have been given direct feedback by our friends about our communication. Statements such as, “I love the way you listen carefully to what I say and wait until I’m finished before you respond,” vs, “I wish you’d hear me out instead of mentally practicing a quick comeback!” give us clear information about how we are doing as we communicate in that moment.
When strong emotions are communicated, the message may be unclear because the client (or nurse) is upset and unable to clearly identify what the heart of the problem is and how to best go about solving it. To be effective, you must be aware of your emotional reactions and avoid the use of emotion-laden communication (even when you feel personally attacked).
Emotion-laden exchanges are cluttered with intense feelings, derogatory remarks, apologies, and so on. To sort out the problem, special listening skills are needed to defuse the emotion and get at the problem. Resist the desire to respond (unhelpfully) to correct the problem right away to get rid of the client’s (or your own) anxiety, anger, or conflict. Too often, we respond by giving quick advice or offering a defensive reply. Instead, use active listening skills.
Case example
Mrs. Mendel, an 82-year-old widow, is admitted to a nursing home accompanied by her daughter, Mrs. Garcia. Mrs. Mendel has lived with her daughter for the past 10 years, however, in the past year she has become increasingly confused and disoriented, and her resistance to eating, bathing, and dressing has made it difficult for her daughter to manage. Her illness is diagnosed as dementia. Mrs. Garcia made the reluctant decision to place her mother in a nursing home and was feeling tremendous guilt about it. She had promised her mother that she would always care for her at home.
Mrs. Garcia visited every day and was often present during mealtimes. Although Mrs. Mendel was gaining weight, Mrs. Garcia was critical of her mother’s care and especially the quality of the meals. One day she came to the nurses’ station and shouted, “The food you are giving my mother is totally unacceptable. You can’t expect her to eat that!”
This is an example of an emotion-laden interaction similar to many that take place daily in hospitals and long-term care facilities. If you were the nurse, how would you have responded? What would you have felt? Would you have become defensive? Would you have argued that Mrs. Mendel was showing remarkable signs of improvement now that she was at the nursing home? Would you have shouted, “Nobody speaks to me that way!”
Situations such as placing a loved one in long-term care involve feelings of loss, vulnerability, and fear. Family members must give over control to strangers, often in institutions that seem strange, impersonal, and frightening with cultures very different from their own. At the root of every emotional outburst is a problem. What, exactly, is the problem in this case example, and whose problem is it? Mrs. Garcia would say that the problem is that her mother is not being treated well. Therefore, the nursing home and food are the problems. The nurse might say that the problem is that Mrs. Garcia is feeling helpless about her mother’s illness and lashed out in frustration. Both are correct from their own way of seeing the world. If the nurse maintains that he or she is right, it will not solve the problem. To resolve the problem, it is the nurse’s responsibility to take the client’s view (in this case, Mrs. Garcia, as Mrs. Mendel’s closest relative, is the client). The nurse can resolve this uncomfortable situation and at the same time avoid taking blame for the situation by active listening and the use of “I” messages.
Clear Sending—Use of “I” Statements
When an individual feels distressed and wants to communicate to another person that he or she is upset, clear communication is facilitated with “I” messages. “I” messages (“I think” or “I feel,” rather than the commonly used editorial “they,” or “you,” or “everyone”) are most effective for resolving problems.3
Many people have a tendency to blame when they feel uncomfortable. An example in which the nurse blames the client might be: “You keep making suggestive remarks. I’m not going to be able to help you if you keep talking that way.” In this case, whose problem is it? If I am upset, the problem is mine. The following response using an “I” message is more likely to resolve the problem: “I’m feeling very frustrated. I’m trying to help you learn about your diabetes and I’m feeling uncomfortable with the things you are saying. Let’s talk about this.”