Ethical considerations
When caring for dying patients, you’ll almost certainly encounter ethical challenges as varied as the patients themselves. However, certain topics tend to arise over and over. Some of the most common areas of ethical concern involve when and how to shift from curative to palliative care, establishing trust with the patient and family, refocusing hope for the patient and family, providing appropriate information, maintaining confidentiality and privacy, relieving the patient’s pain, and withdrawing treatment.
Entering end-of-life care
At some point during a failing treatment process, the focus begins to shift from cure to palliation, and end-of-life care begins. The decision to enter hospice or simply to begin gradually stopping aggressive treatments rests first and foremost with the patient. The patient is the only one who knows when it’s time to stop seeking aggressive or curative treatments and instead to seek comfort measures and support for quality of life throughout the dying process.
Of course, it’s important for the family — however the patient defines that term — to be involved in deciding when the time is most appropriate to move from cure to care. But ultimately, the final decision rests exclusively with the patient. Establishing and protecting this right for the patient and his family is your ethical responsibility, allowing the patient to maintain a sense of control over his future and his autonomy as an adult.
Establishing trust and refocusing hope
In end-of-life care, as much as in any arena of nursing, mutual trust forms the foundation of a therapeutic nurse-patient relationship. The patient must be able to trust that you are both competent and knowledgeable, a capable and reliable practitioner. In return, you must be able to trust that the patient is providing accurate information and expressing thoughts and feelings to the best of his ability. This is the only way you can confidently plan and provide care that meets the patient’s physical, emotional, spiritual, and cultural needs. When trust is breached on either side of the relationship, your ability to help the patient achieve his goals is threatened.
Before making the decision to begin end-of-life care, the patient and his family may have hoped for cure, for recovery, for life to continue as it was before the patient became seriously ill. Once the patient decides to change his treatment focus, he takes the first step toward his individualized dying process. To navigate this process, he and his family must recognize the futility of their earlier hopes, a recognition that can be even more devastating if it leads to hopelessness.
Hope is an intangible quality that lets us overlook a present discomfort in order to achieve a desired goal. One of your most important roles — both clinical and ethical — at this time is to help the patient and family maintain a sense of hope by refocusing on attainable goals. (See Transforming the meaning of hope.)
This task isn’t easy, and you may struggle with the awkward balance between truthfulness and hopefulness. In fact, years ago, it was common for physicians to withhold a diagnosis of terminal disease in an effort to keep the patient from sinking into hopelessness. Some even created an elaborate pretense to avoid discussing the inevitability of the patient’s death, instead choosing to manipulate conversations in the hope that the patient would discover the truth of his diagnosis for himself without being told by others. Although remnants of this kind of thinking remain, especially among physicians uncomfortable discussing death, experts in death and dying agree that this approach removes the patient’s autonomy and opportunity to complete crucial goals before he dies.
Naturally, you never want to dispense information in a callous or insensitive way, even if what you say is technically true. For example, in even the bleakest situation, never say that nothing more can be done for the patient. (See Power of suggestion, page 26.) Be honest with the patient about the symptoms he likely will experience and the methods that can be used to manage those symptoms. Explain that his care team will do everything possible to ease his transition. And help the patient refocus his hope.
Hope for a patient approaching the end of life can be maintained through the idea of transcending self. This can occur as the patient reaches out to
others, accepts help, experiences pleasure from his surroundings, and reminisces about his life. Meaning can be found through creation of a legacy, letting go of meaningless activities, and living in the moment. The end of life can be seen as a time of reflection, achievement, and continued opportunity. With this view, it’s clear that failure to disclose important information at appropriate times and with the appropriate sensitivity may limit or remove the patient’s opportunities for growth and satisfaction with his life.
others, accepts help, experiences pleasure from his surroundings, and reminisces about his life. Meaning can be found through creation of a legacy, letting go of meaningless activities, and living in the moment. The end of life can be seen as a time of reflection, achievement, and continued opportunity. With this view, it’s clear that failure to disclose important information at appropriate times and with the appropriate sensitivity may limit or remove the patient’s opportunities for growth and satisfaction with his life.
Comfort & Care
Transforming the meaning of hope
When a patient and his family must relinquish their hope for recovery, you can help refocus their hope to other important, attainable goals, such as these:
Hope for a comfortable death without pain or discomfort
Hope for the patient to reaffirm — or discover for the first time — the value of his life
Hope for the resolution of unresolved issues
Hope for the patient’s affirmation or discovery of comforting spiritual beliefs
Hope for quality of life
Hope for the patient’s ability to accomplish his wishes during his final days
In addition, address the patient’s specific needs. Help him understand and embrace the things for which he can hope, including that he’ll have:
care throughout the dying process — that he won’t be abandoned
culturally respectful care
as much autonomy and personal control as possible
permission and encouragement to reflect on the implications of his diagnosis and prognosis; to identify and explore his thoughts, feelings, and needs; to tell his story often and in detail; to reaffirm his identify and the value of his life; to reflect on his life and to grieve current and past losses
time with family and friends
time to address unfinished personal business, to complete financial responsibilities, and to plan for the distribution of his assets
help in discussing, developing, and finalizing the documents that pertain to end-of-life decision-making
accurate, timely, reliable information at a level of detail tailored to his wishes
Expert Insights
Power of suggestion
Last week I overheard an oncology nurse tell a patient receiving chemotherapy that his type of cancer has no cure. The patient, who’d been responding well to treatment, told me later that although he knew his prognosis was poor, her comments made him wonder, What’s the point? Now he’s thinking about stopping chemotherapy.
When I spoke to the nurse about how her remarks had affected the patient, she said she was doing him a favor by telling him the truth. According to her, “It’s not right to give patients false hope.”
What do you think?— C.W., Alberta
Not only is giving a prognosis way outside a nurse’s scope of practice, a statement like hers is insensitive and unethical.
Thirty-two years ago I sat in a lecture hall and heard Elisabeth Kübler-Ross tell us never to take away a patient’s hope. Hope is always available, no matter how poor the prognosis. It’s a lesson I’ve never forgotten.
Regardless of prognosis, a nurse’s attitude can influence a patient’s survival and quality of life. Consider this study: Nurses gave analgesics to two groups of patients. With one group, they interacted minimally. With the other group, they spoke softly, exuded caring and empathy, and reassured patients that the drug would ease their pain. Talk about the power of suggestion: Patients in the second group needed less continued analgesia than those in the first group. We also know that chemotherapy is more effective when patients are told to visualize cancer cells being killed.
We need to use every available tool to support seriously ill patients, especially if the prognosis is poor.
The best way to help our patients is not to volunteer bad news, but to listen so well to their concerns that they truly feel they’ve been heard. We need to bring a humbleness to the bedside that allows the patient to tell us he’s dying. We are never to tell him — unless he asks. And even then, the response must be supportive. For example, “The cancer has gotten very difficult to control, but you need to know that we’re your team and we’re going to see this through together.”