Animal-Assisted Therapy



Animal-Assisted Therapy


Susan O’Conner-Von



The domestication of animals began more than 12,000 years ago and continues today as animals play a significant role in human life (Lindsay, 2000). Much of what was known about the animal-human bond was anecdotal in nature until recently (Pavlides, 2008). Research examining the use of animals as a complementary or alternative therapy is based on studies about pet ownership. It is evident—with approximately 70 million pet dogs and 74 million pet cats in the United States—that pets play an important role in people’s lives (American Veterinary Medical Association, 2012a). Pets can help provide companionship, promote dialogue and social interaction, facilitate exercise, increase feelings of security, mitigate the effects of stress, be a source of consistency, and be a comfort to touch (Arkow, 2011). The healing power of pets is “their capacity to make the atmosphere safe for emotions, the spiritual side of healing; whatever you are feeling, you can express it around your pet and not be judged” (Becker, 2002, p. 80).

In a comparative study examining the impact of pet ownership in childhood on young adults’ social characteristics and professional choices, those who owned a pet in childhood retrospectively rated their pet higher than television, relatives, and neighbors in terms of social support received during childhood (Vizek, Arambasic, Kerestes, Kuterovac & Vlahovic-Stetic, 2001). The sample comprised 356 college students at a mean age of 21 years (68% women, 32% men). A total of 74% of the sample had pets (mostly dogs) during childhood and were found to be more empathetic and expressed more altruistic attitudes than those
students who did not own a pet in childhood. Moreover, those students who had a pet in childhood were more likely to choose a career in the helping professions.

The role that animals play in healing environments was first documented in records from 9th-century Belgium where animals were used with persons with physical disabilities, followed by 18th-century England where animals were used with people with mental illness (Pavlides, 2008). Florence Nightingale wrote of the connection between animals and health in 1860 by suggesting that pets were perfect companions for the sick, especially those individuals with chronic health conditions (Nightingale, 1859/1992).

The 1970s launched the beginning of widespread interest in the interaction between animals and humans in the health care setting. In 1976, Elaine Smith, an American registered nurse, observed the benefits of pets in the health care setting while working in England. She noticed how patients reacted positively to the visits of a chaplain and his golden retriever. Upon returning to the United States, Smith introduced the concept of pet therapy into health care settings and founded Therapy Dogs International (2012). The goal of creating Therapy Dogs International was to formally test dogs so they could be certified, insured, and registered as volunteer therapy dogs. In 1977, the Delta Foundation was established to study the human-animal bond and the potential use of animal-assisted therapy (AAT). Scientific research in this area began in the 1980s, with an important step forward by the National Institutes of Health convening a conference in 1987 on the health benefits of pets (Fine & Beck, 2010). During the 1990s the focus was the establishment of professional standards and guidelines with the development of the Standards of Practice for Animal-Assisted Activities and Animal-Assisted Therapy (Delta Society, 1996). In 2008, the National Institute of Child and Human Development convened a conference to discuss the need for clarity and well-designed research examining the animal/human bond (Fine & Beck, 2010). Carefully designed studies provide the evidence needed to increase acceptance of AAT as a credible complementary therapy.




SERVICE ANIMAL

A service animal was originally defined in the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 as any animal trained to do work for the benefit of a person with a physical or emotional disability (U.S. Department of Justice, 2010). As of March 15, 2011, only dogs are recognized as service animals under Title II (state and local government services) or Title III (public accommodations and commercial facilities) of the Americans with Disabilities Act. Service dogs or guide dogs are trained specifically for the service they are providing: sight, sound, movement, or support. Once service animals are certified, they have federally approved access to accompany their owners anywhere. Service dogs are considered working animals, not pets. Although there is increased awareness and acceptance of therapy dogs in
health care and public settings, such dogs do not receive federal protection or the same rights as service dogs who assist people with physical or emotional disabilities (U.S. Department of Justice, 2010).


SCIENTIFIC BASIS

Many studies indicate that there are physical and/or psychological benefits derived from human-animal bonds. Most of the research that has examined the physical benefits of AAT has focused on an animal’s ability to attenuate a person’s response to stress. When an individual becomes stressed, the sympathetic nervous system releases a cascade of hormones such as cortisol, aldosterone, and adrenaline. Stress-reduction strategies, such as petting an animal, can assist in reducing the build-up of these stress hormones (Wolff & Frishman, 2005). Likewise, the hormone oxytocin can lower blood pressure, lower cortisol levels, increase the pain threshold and have an antianxiety effect. One of the best ways to increase oxytocin levels is through positive physical touch, such as petting an animal (Chandler, 2012). Research that has examined the psychological benefits of AAT has explored the stress-reducing benefits the animal provides through social support (Arkow, 2011).


PHYSICAL CONDITIONS

The research investigating the impact of AAT on physical conditions has concentrated on cardiovascular disease, seizure disorders, dementia, and pain management.


Cardiovascular Disease

The study of the relationship between pets and their positive health effects on a human’s cardiovascular system dates back to 1929 (Wolff & Frishman, 2005). Several studies demonstrated the effect of pet ownership on survival after myocardial infarction. Friedmann, Katcher, Lynch, and Thomas (1980) conducted the seminal longitudinal research examining the effect of pet ownership on survival for 92 adult patients after myocardial infarction. Only 5% of the subjects who owned pets died within 1 year after hospitalization, whereas 28% of those who were not pet owners died during the same interval.

Another study by Friedmann and Thomas (1995), examining pet ownership and 1-year survival after myocardial infarction, included the severity of cardiac disease. For the 368 patients in this investigation, disease severity and pet ownership were found to positively affect survival, whereas marital status and living situations did not.


In the Cardiac Arrhythmia Suppressions Trial (CAST) by Friedmann and Thomas (2003), the investigators examined the effect of owning a pet on heart rate variability (HRV) for patients after recovery from a myocardial infarction. As a noninvasive method of showing risk assessment after myocardial infarction, a depressed HRV predicts cardiac complications and increased mortality. Pet owners in this study had a higher HRV, thus supporting the hypothesis that survival differences between pet owners and non-pet owners were due to differences in the autonomic modulation of the heart, therefore providing long-term cardiac benefits and increased survival rates.

In work specifically examining the effects of AAT on hemodynamic measures and state anxiety, 76 adult patients (44 men and 32 women) with advanced heart failure were randomized to: (a) a 12-minute AAT session with a therapy dog; (b) a 12-minute visit with a volunteer; or (c) the control group, which included usual care (Cole, Gawlinski, Steers, & Kotlerman, 2007). Using a repeated-measures experimental design, data were collected at baseline, 8 minutes, and 16 minutes. The results revealed that, compared with the control group, the AAT group had significantly greater decreases in systolic pulmonary artery pressure during and after the AAT intervention and significantly greater decreases in pulmonary capillary wedge pressures during and after the AAT intervention. Moreover, after the intervention, patients in the AAT group had the greatest decrease in state anxiety, compared with the other two groups.


Seizure Disorders

The use of animals as an important component of the treatment plan for subjects with epilepsy was first documented in 1867 in Germany (Fontaine, 2011). Over the last several decades, a number of investigations have examined the value of dogs in the care of patients with seizure disorders. A survey of 122 families who had a child with epilepsy reported that, of those living with a dog, 15% of the dogs could predict seizure onset at least 80% of the time (Kirton, Wirrell, Zhang, & Hamiwka, 2004). In addition, 50% of the dogs exhibited behaviors that were protective of the child, such as lying on top of the child during a seizure or pushing the child away from stairs.


Dementia

For more than 2 decades, studies have supported the use of AAT with patients with degenerative cognitive disorders. For patients with dementia, interacting with an animal can improve short-term memory and communication (Tyberg & Frishman, 2008) and trigger long-term memory (Laun, 2003). The presence of a therapy dog can decrease agitation and
aggression, while increasing social behaviors among patients with dementia (Filan & Llewellyn-Jones, 2006). Indeed, the presence of fish aquariums in a long-term-care facility was associated with increased weights and improved nutritional status among 62 patients with Alzheimer’s disease. These residents were more attentive in the presence of the aquarium, stayed at the dining room table longer, and required less nutritional supplements (Edwards & Beck, 2002). Research specifically examining problem behaviors in patients with dementia found significantly fewer problem behaviors after placement of a dog in the health care facility (McCabe, Baun, Speich, & Agrawal, 2002).


Pain Management


Adult Pain Management

Nurses are acutely aware of the importance of including complementary therapies in providing pain management for patients. Most studies examining animal-assisted therapy in health care have been conducted in acute care settings. Marcus et al. (2012a) evaluated the effects of brief therapy dog visits in an outpatient adult chronic pain clinic compared to time spent in a waiting room without a therapy dog. The sample consisted of 235 patients, 34 family/friends, and 26 staff for a total of 295 therapy dog visits. Participants were able to spend clinic waiting time with a certified therapy dog or in the clinic waiting room. Significant improvements were reported on pain, mood, and other measures of distress among those patients who spent time with the therapy dog, compared to those who chose to remain in the clinic waiting room. Significant improvements were also reported by family/friends and staff after therapy dog visits. Study results revealed that therapy dog visits can significantly improve the feelings of well-being in this patient population.


Pediatric Pain Management

Sobo, Eng, and Kassity-Krich (2006) examined the effectiveness of canine visitation therapy (CVT) on children’s postoperative pain in a pediatric hospital. The convenience sample consisted of 25 English-speaking children, ages 5 years to 18 years. Each patient received a one-time visit after surgery by a West Highland terrier named Lizzy and could choose the level of interaction with the dog. In high interaction, the child actively played and walked with the dog; in low interaction, the dog would do an occasional trick for the child; and in passive interaction, the dog would sit quietly with the child. Despite the small sample size, there was a significant decrease in pain perception after the dog visitation. Moreover, post-CVT interviews with each child revealed eight themes, the dog (1) brought
pleasure or happiness, (2) provided distraction from the pain, (3) was fun, (4) provided company, (5) was calming, (6) reminded them of home, (7) was nice to cuddle with, and (8) eased the pain.


PSYCHOLOGICAL CONDITIONS

The use of animals for treatment of people with mental conditions dates back to 1792 at the York Retreat in England. It was observed that the farm animals helped to enhance the humanity of those with emotional disorders (Altschiller, 2011). The goal was to lessen the use of medications and physical restraints by helping residents learn self-control through the care of animals (Fontaine, 2011). More recently, in 1964, American child psychotherapist Boris Levinson (who is considered to be the father of animalassisted therapy) coined the term “pet therapy.” Levinson first described the therapeutic effects of companionship with his dog, Jingles, for withdrawn children living in a residential mental health program. The dog served as an ice-breaker and opened communication to establish a positive relationship for effective therapy (Altschiller, 2011). Since the 1960s, a number of studies have been conducted to examine the effects of AAT for patients hospitalized on psychiatric units. It has been found that AAT can promote feelings of safety and comfort along with a nonevaluative external focus for patients who are not fearful of animals or have a negative attitude toward them (Odendaal, 2000). Specifically, older patients with schizophrenia who were exposed to AAT showed growth in communication, interpersonal contact with others, and activities of daily living (Barak, Savorai, Mavashev, & Beni, 2001).


Military Personnel

Veterans can experience negative physical, emotional, and psychological effects from their experiences in war. As early as the 1940s, the beneficial effect of working with animals was evident in returning World War II veterans who recovered at the Army Air Corps Convalescent Hospital in New York (Fontaine, 2011). Today, there are several million veterans in our country, many of whom suffer from posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) (Matuszek, 2010). Over the past decade, animal-assisted therapy has become more commonplace in veterans’ hospitals, with the Department of Defense allocating funding to examine the effectiveness of its use. In addition, in March 2011, the Americans with Disabilities Act approved PTSD as a qualification of need for a service dog (Arkow, 2011). Veterans suffering with PTSD can apply for a service dog through organizations such as Veterans Moving Forward (2012) (www.vetsfwd.org). Although research to support the use of a service or therapy dog for
individuals with PTSD is at an early stage, veterans report that these dogs help to manage their PTSD symptoms such as anxiety, panic attacks, and fear (Arkow, 2011).

A recent pretest, posttest nonrandomized control group study evaluated the effects of animal-assisted therapy on Wounded Warriors in transition (N = 24) attending an Occupational Therapy Life Skills Program (Beck et al., 2012). Although significant differences were not found between the groups on most measures (mood, stress, resilience, fatigue, and function), anecdotal information indicated the participants expressed pleasure being with the dogs and did not want the experience to end.

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Jul 14, 2016 | Posted by in NURSING | Comments Off on Animal-Assisted Therapy

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access